2024
WISE Score
Amazon
A slow-burn Dutch thriller that turns a quiet countryside summer into a messy, sexy, and historical reckoning.
4.3
4.3View →Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)
The Safekeep is a brilliant, uncomfortable, and deeply 'adult' novel. It’s not 'wholesome' in the sense of being light or fuzzy—it’s a story about the things we hide under the floorboards and the people we try to keep out.
If you’re looking for a beach read that actually has a brain and a backbone, this is it. Just don't expect a clean, happy ending where everyone shakes hands. It’s a gut-punch wrapped in beautiful prose.
This is strictly for adults and very mature older teens. Between the explicit 'sensual' scenes and the heavy psychological weight of the post-war Dutch setting, it’s not something to hand off to a middle schooler.
This is a story built on obsession, paranoia, and 'fury-fueled' resentment. It’s emotionally heavy and intentionally unsettling, focusing on the messy friction between two women rather than kindness or cooperation.
The plot is a masterclass in tension, taking a standard 'unwelcome guest' trope and twisting it into a sharp exploration of historical memory and forbidden desire. It’s atmospheric and vividly realized.
Marketed as 'deeply sexy' and 'infused with sex,' this isn't for kids. It contains mature psychological themes, explicit sexual content, and the 'darker parts' of WWII history that would be jarring for a younger reader.
It offers profound insight into the post-war Dutch experience and the lingering trauma of the Holocaust. It’s a challenging, award-winning piece of literature that forces readers to confront how history is 'kept' or hidden.
The first half of the book feels like a classic "stranger in the house" thriller. Isabel is a woman who finds comfort in the exact placement of her silver spoons, and Eva is the whirlwind who ruins that order. It’s easy to think you’re reading a standard mystery where the "missing" items are the main event. But the story undergoes a massive vibe shift about halfway through. It pivots from a cold, detached study of a lonely woman into a visceral, erotic, and psychological obsession.
If you have an older teen who gravitates toward the "terrible secrets" found in something like The Lake, they might find the first hundred pages familiar. But The Safekeep is far more dense and literary. It doesn't use secrets as simple plot twists; it uses them as explosives that destroy the characters' lives.
We’ve seen plenty of WWII stories, but this one focuses on the "quiet" year of 1961. The craters are filled in, but the ownership of the houses and the items inside them is still a raw, bleeding wound. This isn't a story about soldiers. It’s a story about the people who stayed behind and kept things that didn't belong to them.
The "Jewish Book Award" win is a major clue to the book's soul. It’s looking at the Dutch countryside through a lens of complicity and denial. It shares that sense of "prestige grit" you find in The Luminaries, where the setting is beautiful but the social undercurrents are ugly. It’s less about the Holocaust as a historical event and more about the Holocaust as a haunting presence in a kitchen or a bedroom.
This is a high-IQ book, but it’s also a high-heat book. The "sensual" descriptions mentioned by critics aren't just window dressing. They are central to the plot. If your teen is used to the fast-paced, "Criminal Minds" energy of Killer Instinct, they might find the pacing here frustratingly slow. The Safekeep is a slow burn in the truest sense. It builds pressure until it finally cracks.
Don't hand this to a kid who just wants a puzzle to solve. This is for the reader who wants to feel uncomfortable. It’s for the person who wants to see how history actually feels when it’s sitting in your living room, refusing to leave. It’s a masterful debut, but it’s one that requires a certain level of emotional mileage to fully appreciate.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
