Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is one of those rare YA books that actually captures what it feels like to be a teen without being preachy or cringe. The verse format is genius—it makes the book fly by while also mirroring how Xiomara's mind works, processing everything through poetry.

The awards are well-deserved. It's honest about body image, first love, and the suffocating feeling of strict religious upbringing without demonizing anyone. Xiomara's mother isn't a villain; she's doing what she thinks is right. That nuance is rare and valuable.

Yes, there's swearing and sexual content, but it's age-appropriate for older teens and handled with emotional authenticity rather than gratuitousness. The 'heavy petting' that parent reviews mention is basically making out—this isn't graphic.

If you have a 14-17 year old, especially one who thinks they don't like reading or poetry, this is the book. It's also particularly powerful for kids navigating cultural/religious identity or anyone who feels unheard. Just know it's firmly high school content, not middle school.

Age Fit

Best for ages 14-17 who can handle mature themes about sexuality, family conflict, and religious tension. The verse format makes it accessible, but the content is solidly high school territory. Not appropriate for middle schoolers unless they're quite mature.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

78

Models authentic self-expression, standing up for beliefs, and finding voice in the face of family pressure. The protagonist navigates first love, religious conflict, and body image with emotional honesty. Contains some swearing and 'heavy petting' but in context of a genuine coming-of-age story about a teen finding her identity. The family dynamics are complex and sometimes painful (strict religious mother, emotional suppression) but ultimately about growth and understanding.

Imaginative

91

Novel-in-verse format is inherently creative, introducing teens to slam poetry and showing how writing can be a powerful tool for self-expression. The protagonist pours her feelings into poetry, modeling creative outlet for frustration and passion. The verse format makes it accessible and dynamic, breaking traditional narrative structure. Celebrates artistic voice and the transformative power of words.

Safe

72

Contains mature themes appropriate for teens: some swearing, references to sexual content ('heavy petting'), body image issues, strict religious upbringing, family conflict, and forbidden romance. Common Sense Media and Bark recommend ages 14-15+. No graphic violence or truly shocking content, but deals with real teen experiences including physical attraction and pushback against parental control. The content is honest rather than gratuitous, but definitely not for younger kids who might stumble upon it.

Enriching

93

Winner of National Book Award, Printz Award, and Pura Belpré Award for good reason. Offers authentic Afro-Latina representation and tackles identity, faith, family expectations, feminism, and self-advocacy. Introduces slam poetry as an art form and models how creative expression can be healing. The verse format makes it accessible for reluctant readers while delivering powerful themes about finding your voice, standing up to oppression (even within family), and navigating cultural/religious tension. Quick read with lasting impact.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

The verse format makes it incredibly readable—even reluctant readers fly through this in a day or two
Authentic representation of Afro-Latina experience, strict religious upbringing, and the tension between family expectations and personal identity
Introduces slam poetry as an art form and models creative expression as a tool for processing complex emotions
Multiple major awards (National Book Award, Printz, Pura Belpré) and it actually deserves them—this isn't boring prestige literature
Tackles body image, first love, religious conflict, and finding your voice with emotional honesty that resonates with modern teens

⚠

What to Watch For

Mature content including swearing, sexual references (kissing, 'heavy petting'), and frank discussion of physical attraction—definitely 14+ territory
The family dynamics can be painful: strict religious mother, emotional suppression, and conflict over autonomy
Themes of rebellion against parental/religious authority might spark conversations about your own family's values
Some teens from strict religious backgrounds might find it either incredibly validating or potentially uncomfortable depending on where they are in their own journey

Conversation Starters

"Xiomara uses poetry to express feelings she can't say out loud. What's your outlet when you need to process something big?"
"The book shows tension between Xiomara's mother's faith and Xiomara's own beliefs. How do you navigate when family expectations don't match what feels right to you?"
"Talk about the slam poetry club—have you ever seen spoken word or slam poetry? Want to check some out together?"
"Xiomara feels like her body changed and suddenly everyone treated her differently. How does that land for you?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

The Poet X