Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Katherine Applegate continues to prove why she won the Newbery Medal with this emotionally sophisticated third installment in the Ivan universe. Ruby's story doesn't pull punches—her mother was killed by poachers, climate change is real and affecting wildlife, and grief is complicated—but Applegate handles it all with the kind of grace that makes kids feel respected, not lectured.
The novel-in-verse format is a smart choice here, giving readers breathing room between heavy moments and making a 200+ page book feel approachable. Some kids will devour it in an afternoon; others might need to take it slower, and that's fine.
This isn't escapist entertainment—it's the kind of book that builds empathy and makes kids think about their place in the world. The #1 bestseller status and 4.8 Amazon rating suggest Applegate has threaded the needle of making important topics genuinely engaging. If your kid loved Ivan and Bob, this is a no-brainer. If they haven't read those yet, start there—Ruby's story will hit harder with the full context.
Age Fit
Best for grades 5-8 (ages 10-13) who can handle emotionally complex themes about loss, trauma, and conservation. The verse format and animal narration make heavy topics accessible, but this isn't light reading—it's for kids ready to sit with sad feelings and big questions about the world.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Katherine Applegate delivers emotionally mature storytelling that centers family, love, and loss without being saccharine. Ruby's journey processing trauma from losing her mother to poachers and adjusting to sanctuary life models healthy emotional processing. The friendship between Ruby, Ivan, and Bob demonstrates genuine cooperation and support. The novel-in-verse format creates natural pacing that gives readers space to breathe between heavy moments.
Imaginative
82
Applegate's use of first-person animal narration invites kids to imagine the world through Ruby's elephant perspective. The novel-in-verse format encourages creative reading and appreciation of literary devices like personification and imagery. Ruby's memories of the African savannah contrast with her current sanctuary life, building rich sensory worlds. However, this is the third book in a series following established characters, so the imaginative territory feels more like expansion than groundbreaking exploration.
Safe
72
Common Sense Media flags 'heavy, traumatic stuff' including climate change impact on wildlife and a poaching industry that kills Ruby's mother for ivory. While these are important topics handled with care, they're genuinely difficult content that could upset sensitive readers. The book doesn't shy away from grief and loss. That said, Applegate is a master at age-appropriate emotional depth—nothing is gratuitous or graphic, just real. Parents should know what they're walking into, but it's not unsafe, just substantive.
Enriching
86
This is a Newbery Medal-winning author tackling climate change, wildlife conservation, the ivory trade, and processing trauma through an accessible middle-grade lens. The novel-in-verse format builds literary appreciation and exposes kids to poetic devices. Ruby's story builds empathy for both animals and the complex realities of conservation. The African orphanage backstory provides cultural context. It's emotionally intelligent without being preachy, and the 4.8 Amazon rating plus #1 NYT bestseller status suggests it's actually engaging kids, not just parents.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Katherine Applegate is a master at making kids cry in the best way—emotionally intelligent storytelling that doesn't talk down to readers
Novel-in-verse format makes heavy topics digestible and can hook reluctant readers who feel intimidated by dense chapter books
Tackles real-world conservation issues (poaching, climate change, wildlife sanctuaries) through a story kids actually want to read
Ruby's friendship with Ivan and Bob models genuine care and support through difficult times
The African savannah flashbacks provide cultural richness and sensory world-building that expands beyond typical middle-grade settings
⚠
What to Watch For
Ruby's mother is killed by poachers for ivory—it's handled with care but it's genuinely sad and could upset sensitive readers
Climate change and its impact on wildlife is a recurring theme; some families may want to discuss this together
This is book three; while it can stand alone, kids will get more out of it if they've read The One and Only Ivan and Bob first
The verse format means fewer words per page but requires different reading stamina—some kids love it, others find it choppy
Conversation Starters
"Ruby remembers both happy and sad things about her life before the circus. What memories do you think about when you're feeling homesick or missing someone?"
"The book talks about poaching and why people kill elephants for their tusks. Why do you think this happens, and what could help stop it?"
"Ruby, Ivan, and Bob all came from different places but became a family. What makes someone family to you?"
"If you could tell a story from an animal's point of view, which animal would you pick and what would they say about humans?"
