The Problem with Photorealism
Disney's 2019 'live-action' (it's actually 100% digital) remake of The Lion King is a fascinating case study in 'just because you can, doesn't mean you should.' By chasing total realism, director Jon Favreau sacrificed the very thing that made the original work: the ability for the characters to emote.
When Simba is grieving, his face remains a static, realistic lion face. In the 1994 version, his eyebrows, eyes, and mouth conveyed a depth of human sorrow that kids immediately connected with. Here, you have to rely entirely on the voice acting to know how anyone is feeling. It’s a weirdly detached experience.
Seth Rogen to the Rescue
The movie is saved from being a total slog by Timon and Pumbaa. Seth Rogen and Billy Eichner clearly had some room to riff, and their chemistry provides the only moments where the film feels like it’s breathing on its own. Their version of 'The Lion Sleeps Tonight' is a genuine highlight.
If you have a kid who is obsessed with animals or Planet Earth, they will likely be mesmerized by the fur grooming and the way the light hits the savanna. But for kids who want a story they can feel, this version might leave them a bit cold. It’s a movie that is easier to admire than it is to love.