Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the kind of YA that wins major literary prizes and makes English teachers excited—which means it's genuinely good but also genuinely challenging. The magical tree concept is brilliant and original, and Hardinge's prose is legitimately beautiful. Faith is a compelling protagonist navigating Victorian sexism while solving her father's murder.
But let's be real: parent reviews confirm what the synopsis suggests—this is a slow starter that doesn't really catch fire until the last third. If your kid needs action and fast pacing, this will sit unfinished on their nightstand. It's also dark: murder, grief, lies, and the messiness of discovering your idolized parent was deeply flawed.
For the right reader—patient, literary-minded, interested in historical settings and moral complexity—this is excellent. For everyone else, it's going to feel like homework. The 4.2 Amazon rating reflects this divide: people either love the literary merit or bail because it's too slow.
Age Fit
Best for ages 12-16 who enjoy literary mysteries and can handle slow pacing and heavy themes. Strong readers could start at 11, but the Victorian setting, dense prose, and dark subject matter (murder, grief, moral complexity) make this too much for younger middle-graders. Adults who love YA literary fiction will also appreciate it.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
72
Deals with heavy themes including murder, death of a parent, Victorian-era sexism, and revenge, but ultimately centers on a daughter's determination to uncover truth and justice. Faith's character growth is emotionally complex rather than traumatic. The Victorian setting means gender limitations are historically accurate context rather than gratuitous. The pacing is deliberately slow, which some readers find challenging but isn't chaotic or manipulative.
Imaginative
88
The central conceit—a magical tree that bears truth-revealing fruit when fed lies—is genuinely original and thought-provoking. Hardinge's prose is described as 'poetic' and 'beautifully thought-out' with vivid descriptions that transport readers. The mystery structure invites active engagement as Faith pieces together clues. The Victorian island setting and the intersection of science, religion, and magic create rich imaginative territory. Won the Costa Book of the Year, a major UK literary prize.
Safe
68
Contains death of a parent (murder), themes of grief and revenge, and Victorian-era treatment of women that could be upsetting. No graphic violence, sexual content, or inappropriate language for YA. The darkness is psychological rather than explicit. Parent reviews note it's a 'dark and powerful novel' with content warnings for death of parent. For the target YA audience (12+), these themes are handled appropriately, but younger readers encountering this unexpectedly might find it heavy.
Enriching
85
Tackles complex themes: the nature of truth and lies, Victorian gender inequality, the conflict between science and religion, and a daughter's complicated relationship with an imperfect father. Faith is a sharp, observant protagonist who challenges societal expectations. The mystery structure builds critical thinking and deduction skills. Won the Los Angeles Times Book Prize for YA Literature and Boston Globe–Horn Book Award for Fiction. Offers meaningful discussion material about integrity, justice, and the consequences of deception.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Genuinely original magical realism concept that makes you think about truth, lies, and consequences
Faith is a sharp, complex protagonist navigating Victorian sexism while solving a murder—no passive damsel here
Award-winning literary prose that's actually beautiful, not just 'fine for YA'
Tackles meaty themes: gender inequality, science vs. religion, moral ambiguity, and the messiness of idolizing imperfect parents
Mystery structure rewards careful readers who pick up on clues alongside Faith
⚠
What to Watch For
This is a slow burn—parent reviews confirm it takes about 100+ pages to really get going, which will lose impatient readers
Father's death (murder) and grief are central; not light reading
Victorian-era treatment of women and girls is historically accurate but can be frustrating and upsetting
Dense, literary prose requires focus—not beach reading or bedtime wind-down material
Conversation Starters
"Faith discovers her father wasn't the person she thought he was. How do you handle finding out someone you admire has serious flaws?"
"The tree only gives truth when you feed it lies. Would you use it if you had access? What would you want to know?"
"Faith has to pretend to be 'modest and well-mannered' while secretly being curious and sharp. Have you ever felt like you had to hide parts of yourself?"
"The book is set in Victorian times when women couldn't pursue science or education. How would you have handled those limitations?"