Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is one of those YA books that sticks with you. Nancy Farmer doesn't dumb anything down—she drops you into a world where clones are property, humans are turned into zombie workers, and a drug lord rules an entire nation. It's dark, but never gratuitous.
The payoff is huge: Matt's journey from confused child to someone who understands his own humanity is genuinely moving, and the ethical questions (What makes us human? Can you own a person?) are the kind that spark real dinner table debates.
Fair warning: the first 50-100 pages are slow. Farmer is building Matt's world brick by brick, and some kids will bounce off. But if your reader sticks with it, they're in for a National Book Award-winning ride that's both thrilling and thought-provoking. This is the good stuff—the kind of book that makes kids (and adults) think differently about the world.
Age Fit
Best for ages 11-16 who are ready for serious dystopian fiction with mature themes. The conceptual darkness (organ harvesting, dehumanization) and slow-burn pacing make this too heavy for younger readers, but it's a must-read for middle schoolers ready to wrestle with big ethical questions.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
72
Explores heavy themes (cloning, human exploitation, drug cartels) but handles them thoughtfully for YA readers. Models moral courage through Matt's journey to understand his humanity and fight against injustice. Some darkness around power abuse and dehumanization, but the emotional core is about dignity, kindness, and standing up for what's right. Not light reading, but emotionally grounded.
Imaginative
88
Brilliant speculative fiction concept: a clone raised by a drug lord in a dystopian nation called Opium between the US and Mexico. The premise alone sparks huge questions about identity, humanity, and ethics. Nancy Farmer builds a richly detailed world that feels both futuristic and eerily plausible. Invites deep thinking about what makes us human and how power corrupts.
Safe
68
This is YA sci-fi that doesn't pull punches. Contains mature themes including drug trafficking, human cloning for organ harvesting, abuse of power, and characters being treated as less than human. Violence is present but not gratuitous. Drug and alcohol use mentioned in context of the cartel setting. No sexual content or graphic gore, but the conceptual darkness (people kept as 'zombies,' clones created to be harvested) is intense. Appropriate for the 11+ range per parent reviews, but younger kids would find it disturbing.
Enriching
91
This is the kind of book English teachers assign because it works. Tackles bioethics, identity, class systems, immigration, and human rights through compelling storytelling. Makes readers think deeply about what defines humanity and personhood. National Book Award winner for good reason—it builds empathy, challenges assumptions, and leaves you with real questions to wrestle with. The slow-burn pacing actually serves the character development.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
National Book Award winner that actually deserves the hype—this is literary YA done right
Tackles massive ethical questions (What makes us human? Can you own a person?) through gripping storytelling
The world-building is chef's kiss: a drug empire called Opium between the US and Mexico where clones are harvested for organs
Slow burn that rewards patience—starts quietly but builds into an action-packed, thought-provoking ride
Makes kids think about power, justice, and standing up for what's right without being preachy
⚠
What to Watch For
Heavy themes: cloning for organ harvesting, people kept as mindless 'eejits,' drug cartel violence—not graphic but conceptually dark
The first chunk is deliberately slow as Matt's world is established; some kids bounce off before it picks up
Drug and alcohol use is discussed in context (it's literally set in a drug empire), though not glorified
Best for kids who can handle moral complexity and aren't looking for light escapism
Conversation Starters
"If Matt is a clone of El Patrón, does that make him the same person? What makes you... you?"
"The 'eejits' have their intelligence removed to make them obedient workers. How is that different from or similar to slavery?"
"El Patrón loves Matt 'as he loves himself'—because Matt IS himself. Is that real love?"
"If you could clone yourself, would you? What if that clone was going to be used for spare parts?"
"The book is set in 'Opium,' a drug empire. Why do you think Nancy Farmer chose that name and setting?"
