Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is a strong, important YA novel that fills a real gap in representation—queer Muslim teens deserve to see themselves in love stories, and this delivers. The henna art angle is distinctive and culturally rich, and Jaigirdar doesn't shy away from the real pain of being rejected by your family for who you are.
That said, this is not a light read. Multiple reviewers mention it's emotionally difficult, and the parental rejection storyline will hit hard for any teen dealing with unsupportive family. It's enriching precisely because it's real—no magical fix, just the messy work of choosing yourself even when it costs you.
If your teen is navigating LGBTQ+ identity, especially within a religious or cultural context, this could be validating and meaningful. If they're not ready for heavy emotional content, wait a bit. But for the right reader at the right time, this is exactly the kind of book that makes you feel seen.
Age Fit
Best for teens 14 and up who are ready for emotionally complex stories about identity, family conflict, and queer relationships. The themes are mature not because of content warnings, but because they require emotional maturity to process parental rejection and cultural-religious tension.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
78
Models self-acceptance, navigating family conflict with empathy, and healthy relationship development between two teenage girls. The story centers on Nishat's struggle to be authentic while maintaining family bonds—her parents' rejection of her sexuality creates genuine emotional pain, but the narrative doesn't shy away from showing both sides. The competitive tension with Flávia eventually gives way to understanding. Some moments are emotionally heavy (parental rejection, bullying, cultural-religious identity conflict), which is realistic but can be draining. The tone is age-appropriate for teens dealing with real-world complexity.
Imaginative
72
The henna art business competition provides a creative framework that celebrates South Asian cultural artistry. The premise of two girls competing as henna artists is fresh and specific—not your standard YA romance setup. However, the story leans more on emotional realism and relationship dynamics than on world-building or fantastical elements. It invites readers to think about cultural expression, entrepreneurship, and identity, but doesn't push boundaries of genre or form. Solid contemporary YA with a distinctive cultural lens.
Safe
82
No graphic content, violence, or sexual scenes. The main safety consideration is emotional intensity: parental rejection of a queer child, bullying at school, and the painful intersection of religious/cultural identity with sexuality. These themes are handled thoughtfully and age-appropriately for teens, but could be triggering for LGBTQ+ teens experiencing similar family rejection. Common Sense Media reviews and kid reviews confirm some readers found it emotionally difficult. For the target YA audience (14+), these are important, realistic topics presented with care—not gratuitous or exploitative.
Enriching
85
Deeply enriching for teens navigating identity, especially LGBTQ+ Muslim teens who rarely see themselves in YA lit. Explores the complex intersection of faith, culture, sexuality, and family expectations without easy answers. Teaches about Bengali culture, henna artistry, and the immigrant experience in Ireland. Builds empathy for the difficult choices queer teens face in unsupportive environments. Named one of TIME's 100 Best YA Books for good reason—it offers representation, cultural education, and emotional insight. The business competition angle also touches on entrepreneurship and creative expression.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Rare, authentic representation of LGBTQ+ Muslim teens—specifically Bengali Irish experience
Henna art competition is a creative, culturally-rich framework that celebrates South Asian artistry
Doesn't sugarcoat family rejection but shows path toward self-acceptance and chosen family
Named one of TIME's 100 Best YA Books; 4.5 stars on Amazon with strong reader response
Tackles intersection of faith, culture, and sexuality with nuance—no easy answers, just real feelings
⚠
What to Watch For
Emotionally heavy—parental rejection of a queer child is central to the plot and can be painful
Bullying scenes and microaggressions about race and sexuality
Best for teens 14+ who can handle complex identity conflicts without tidy resolutions
Some readers found it difficult to read due to emotional intensity, not content warnings
Conversation Starters
"Nishat's parents say she can be anyone except herself. Have you ever felt like you had to hide part of who you are?"
"The book shows how religion and culture can clash with identity. How do you think people can honor their heritage while being true to themselves?"
"Nishat and Flávia start as competitors but develop feelings. How do you handle situations where someone frustrates you but you're also drawn to them?"
"What would you do if your best friend or family member came out and their parents rejected them?"