The Gilded Wolves, Book 1 Roshani Chokshi – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

The Gilded Wolves, Book 1 Roshani Chokshi

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2020

80%

WISE Score

4.2

Amazon

Ocean's Eleven meets magical Paris—a diverse found family pulls off impossible heists in this lush, inventive YA fantasy with real emotional stakes.

The Gilded Wolves, Book 1 Roshani Chokshi

book

2020

80%

WISE Score

4.2

Amazon

Ocean's Eleven meets magical Paris—a diverse found family pulls off impossible heists in this lush, inventive YA fantasy with real emotional stakes.

4.2

Jump to

Also rated on

4.2

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is a solid, well-crafted YA fantasy that delivers on its promise: gorgeous world-building, a genuinely likable found family, and enough plot twists to keep older teens engaged. Chokshi's writing is lush without being purple, and the diversity feels organic rather than checklist-y.

That said, it's not for younger teens. The mature themes, sexual content, and morally gray heist premise mean this is firmly in the 15+ camp. Some readers also find the pacing messy and the info-dumping heavy in the first half—it's the kind of book that rewards patience but might lose kids who want immediate action.

If your teen loved Six of Crows or is ready for more complex fantasy with historical grounding, this is a great pick. Just know it's not a light read, and the 'dark and disturbing topics' parents mention on Goodreads are real.

Age Fit

Best for readers 15 and up who can handle mature themes, morally complex characters, and some sexual content. The dense world-building and historical setting also work better for teens who can appreciate the alternate-history elements and stick with slower exposition.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Features a found family of outcasts who work together, with multiple reviews highlighting the 'wholesome and adorable' relationships between characters. The cooperative dynamics and loyalty themes are strong, though the darker mature topics explored (per Goodreads parent feedback) and heist-based morally gray premise prevent a higher score. The emotional core is healthy—these are people looking out for each other—but the context involves theft, revenge, and deliberate risk-taking.

Imaginative

A wildly inventive alternate-history Paris during the 1889 World Fair, blending magical 'Forging' abilities with real historical elements. The puzzle-heist structure, artifact hunt, and world-building around manipulating nature's elements through magical fragments is creative and distinctive. Multiple reviews praise it as 'a masterpiece of imagination' and 'gorgeous, lush' storytelling. The premise invites curiosity about history, magic systems, and problem-solving.

Safe

Common Sense Media and Goodreads parents recommend ages 15+ due to 'dark/disturbing/mature topics' that are 'probably a little much for younger readers.' StoryGraph flags sexual content warnings. No graphic violence or explicit scenes detailed, but the heist premise involves danger, characters are 'deliberately placed in harm's way,' and there are mature themes woven throughout. For the target YA audience (15+), it's appropriately safe, but younger teens might encounter content that feels unexpected or heavy.

Enriching

Rich historical setting (1889 Paris World Fair) with a diverse cast representing different cultures and perspectives. Features a historian character 'caught between two worlds,' explores themes of birthright, social outcasts reclaiming agency, and colonialism/power dynamics in the Order. The puzzle-solving and heist elements encourage critical thinking. However, some reviews note 'info dumping' and messy execution, suggesting the educational elements aren't always seamlessly integrated. Still, the representation, historical grounding, and moral complexity around revenge vs. loyalty offer meaningful discussion points.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

The found-family dynamic is genuinely wholesome and well-earned—six outcasts who actually care about each other, not just a forced ensemble
Alternate-history 1889 Paris with magical 'Forging' abilities creates a rich, imaginative world that blends real history with creative fantasy elements
Diverse cast with meaningful representation—characters from different cultural backgrounds whose identities matter to the story
Puzzle-heist structure keeps the plot moving and rewards readers who pay attention to clues and world-building details
Explores complex themes like revenge, loyalty, colonialism, and the cost of ambition without being preachy

⚠

What to Watch For

Mature content including sexual themes, dark topics, and morally gray characters—Common Sense Media and parents recommend 15+
The heist premise means characters lie, steal, and deliberately endanger themselves, which may not align with younger readers' values
Some reviews mention info-dumping and messy pacing—the world-building is dense and might feel overwhelming at first
Romantic tension and relationships include some sexual content, though not explicit

Conversation Starters

"Séverin is driven by revenge for what was stolen from him. Do you think revenge can ever be justified, or does it just create more problems?"
"The crew are all 'societal outcasts' working together. What makes someone an outcast, and how does that shape who they become?"
"The book is set during the 1889 World Fair in Paris. What do you know about that time period, and how does adding magic change the story?"
"Each character has a special skill that makes them essential to the team. If you were part of a heist crew, what would your role be?"
"The group has to decide between their individual goals and protecting each other. When have you had to make a choice like that?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic