Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Let's be blunt: The Do-Over is a mess. It's the kind of movie that makes you wonder how Netflix greenlit it, even in their early 'throw everything at the wall' phase.

The premise—two guys fake their deaths to escape their boring lives—could have been a clever dark comedy. Instead, it's 101 minutes of tired Sandler shtick: crude sex jokes, casual sexism and homophobia, and a plot that goes nowhere interesting. Critics absolutely destroyed it (9% on Rotten Tomatoes, 22 on Metacritic), and they're not wrong. It's not funny, it's not clever, and it's certainly not family-friendly.

For parents, this is an easy skip. The TV-MA rating is well-earned with constant profanity, sexual content, drug use, and violence. More concerning is the moral vacuum—the protagonists lie, cheat, and behave recklessly without consequence, all played for laughs that never land.

Even if you're looking for mindless adult entertainment, there are infinitely better options. This is the kind of movie that makes you appreciate good comedy by showing you what happens when talented people stop trying.

Age Fit

This is strictly for adults 18+ who enjoy crude, low-brow comedy and can stomach offensive humor. Even at 16 (Common Sense Media's recommendation), the sexism, homophobia, and moral bankruptcy make it a questionable choice. Honestly, even most adults should skip it—the abysmal critical reception suggests it's not worth anyone's time.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

18

This is quintessential low-brow Sandler fare—crude sexual humor, frequent profanity, glorification of lying and identity fraud, and sexist/homophobic jokes throughout. The premise literally centers on faking your own death to escape responsibility. Critics describe it as 'unfunny, sexist, homophobic, stupid' and Christian reviewers rate it 'Extremely Offensive' for its moral content. There's no redemptive arc, no meaningful character growth, just two middle-aged men behaving recklessly with drugs, violence, and sexual promiscuity played for laughs.

Imaginative

22

The fake-death-and-new-identity premise had potential for creativity, but the execution is formulaic Sandler comedy—predictable beats, repetitive low-brow gags, and zero originality in how the story unfolds. The film doesn't invite any creative thinking or spark curiosity; it's a paint-by-numbers buddy comedy that recycles tired tropes. The 9% Rotten Tomatoes critic score and 2.3/5 Letterboxd rating reflect how uninspired and derivative this feels.

Safe

15

TV-MA rating with good reason—frequent profanity, sexual content and innuendo, drug references, violence including a 'violent showdown with a mobster's widow,' and mature themes throughout. Common Sense Media sets the age at 16+. This is absolutely not something you'd want a kid stumbling into. The content is consistently adult-oriented with no guardrails, making it highly inappropriate for family viewing or accidental exposure.

Enriching

8

There's essentially zero enrichment value here. The film doesn't build skills, offer meaningful takeaways, or provide any ethical or cognitive growth. The protagonists lie, cheat, and engage in reckless behavior without consequence or reflection. Even as pure entertainment, it fails—the 9% critic score, 22 Metacritic, and reviews calling it 'unfunny' and 'stupid' indicate it doesn't even succeed at being enjoyably mindless. It's neither enriching nor entertaining.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

If you're an adult who genuinely enjoys low-brow Sandler humor and can overlook sexism, homophobia, and crude jokes, you might find a few laughs
The fake-death premise could have been interesting in more capable hands
David Spade and Adam Sandler have nostalgic chemistry for fans of their '90s work

⚠

What to Watch For

TV-MA for a reason—constant profanity, sexual content, drug references, and violence make this completely inappropriate for anyone under 16
Morally questionable throughout: the heroes lie, commit fraud, and behave recklessly with zero consequences or growth
Sexist and homophobic jokes are baked into the humor—this isn't edgy comedy, it's just lazy and offensive
Critically savaged (9% on Rotten Tomatoes)—even as mindless entertainment, it fails to entertain
The 101-minute runtime feels much longer given the repetitive, unfunny gags

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think the filmmakers thought lying and faking your death would be funny? What message does that send?"
"This movie was panned by critics but some audiences still liked it—what makes comedy subjective?"
"How has comedy changed since 2016? Would jokes like these even get made today?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic