Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is a solid, well-intentioned diversity book that does exactly what it sets out to do: give young kids a framework for talking about skin color in a positive, curious way. Karen Katz wrote it for her adopted daughter from Guatemala, and that personal connection shows in the warmth.
That said, it's not without criticism. Some reviewers—particularly people of color—find the white adoptive parent perspective uncomfortable, like the book is teaching kids to notice and appreciate brown skin from the outside rather than from lived experience. It's a fair critique, and worth considering alongside other diversity books written by authors of color.
The book itself is safe, sweet, and useful for families navigating these conversations with preschoolers and early elementary kids. It's a bit dated (2002) and very much a "message book" rather than a compelling story, so don't expect kids to request it over and over. But as a tool for opening dialogue? It works. Just pair it with other perspectives too.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 3-7, when kids are starting to notice and ask questions about physical differences. The simple text and bold illustrations work for preschoolers, while the identity message resonates through early elementary. Older kids won't be interested—this is squarely a picture book for the young set.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
Celebrates diversity and skin color through a child's innocent, curious lens. Models a warm mother-daughter relationship and positive community interactions. The tone is affirming and gentle, perfect for young children exploring identity and difference without any edge or conflict.
Imaginative
72
Offers a fresh artistic perspective on seeing the world—comparing skin tones to cinnamon, pizza crust, and other familiar objects. The painter's eye approach invites kids to look closely at their world, though the execution is fairly straightforward and didactic rather than wildly creative.
Safe
98
Completely safe for young children. No concerning content whatsoever. One critical review raises concerns about 'racial fetishization' and the white adoptive mother's perspective on brown skin feeling uncomfortable, but this is more about nuanced adult critique than child safety. The book itself contains no triggering material.
Enriching
81
Strong conversation starter about race, identity, and diversity for families with young children. Builds empathy and awareness of difference in an age-appropriate way. The 4.9 Amazon rating suggests parents find it valuable. However, it's a fairly simple lesson book—enriching for its purpose but not deeply layered or challenging beyond the core message.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Opens the door to conversations about race and identity in a gentle, age-appropriate way that doesn't feel preachy
The artist's perspective (comparing skin to cinnamon, peanut butter, etc.) gives kids a concrete, sensory framework for noticing and celebrating difference
Mother-daughter bonding through a neighborhood walk makes it feel warm and relatable
Bold, colorful illustrations that young kids respond to—Karen Katz's signature collage style is visually engaging
4.9 Amazon rating suggests parents actually find it useful as a conversation tool
⚠
What to Watch For
Some critics (particularly people of color) note discomfort with a white adoptive mother writing about brown skin—the perspective can feel like it's observing rather than living the experience
It's a message book, not a story book—there's not much plot or character development, so don't expect deep engagement beyond the lesson
Published in 2002, so while the message holds up, the style and approach feel a bit dated compared to more recent diversity books
Conversation Starters
"What color would you use to paint your skin? What does it remind you of?"
"Who in our family or neighborhood has different skin colors? What do you notice?"
"Lena sees all these beautiful colors when she really looks. What other things come in lots of different shades?"
"How do you think it feels when someone notices your skin color? Is it different from noticing your hair or eyes?"
