Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is a perfectly nice Hanukkah picture book that does what it sets out to do: teach a gentle lesson about reaching out to lonely neighbors while explaining latkes and menorahs. The 4.8 Amazon rating suggests parents appreciate it, and it's a solid classroom or library pick during December.
That said, it's also kind of... sleepy. Published in 1997, it has that earnest, straightforward quality of late-90s picture books that modern kids might find a little slow. There's not much humor, no real plot twist, and the 'stubborn' Mrs. Greenberg isn't stubborn enough to be interesting. It's the literary equivalent of a warm potato latke: comforting, wholesome, but not exactly thrilling.
If you're looking for a Hanukkah book for young kids and want something safe and sweet, this works. But if you want something with more spark or staying power, keep browsing.
Age Fit
Perfect for preschool through early elementary (ages 3-7), especially during Hanukkah season or when talking about community and kindness. Older kids will find it too simple and dated.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Sweet story about kindness, community, and reaching out to someone who is lonely. Rachel's initiative to invite Mrs. Greenberg models generosity and persistence without being preachy. The intergenerational friendship and theme of inclusion during a family celebration hits the right notes emotionally.
Imaginative
62
Straightforward narrative with limited creative spark. Nancy Cote's illustrations are described as 'unique' and 'jovial' with 'repeated lines and patterns,' which adds visual interest, but the story itself follows a predictable arc. It's pleasant but doesn't invite much exploration or wonder beyond the immediate plot.
Safe
98
Picture book with zero concerning content. Simple story about borrowing potatoes and inviting a neighbor to dinner. No violence, scary elements, or mature themes. Completely appropriate for young children.
Enriching
74
Introduces Hanukkah traditions (latkes, the eight nights) in an accessible way for kids unfamiliar with the holiday. Models reaching out to lonely neighbors and the value of community. The 'stubborn' Mrs. Greenberg adds a bit of character complexity. Solid social-emotional learning around inclusion, but not particularly deep or memorable.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Models genuine kindness—Rachel reaches out to a lonely neighbor without being asked
Introduces Hanukkah traditions (latkes, menorah, family gatherings) in a low-key, accessible way
Nice intergenerational friendship that shows persistence pays off