Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Play

Screenwise Verdict

Super Mario Kart is a legitimate piece of gaming history—the granddaddy of every kart racer your kids play today. It's wholesome, creative, and blissfully free of modern gaming's worst impulses (no microtransactions, no loot boxes, no strangers screaming in chat).

But let's be real: this game is 30+ years old. The graphics look like someone smeared Vaseline on a pixel art project. The controls feel like you're driving on an ice rink covered in butter. The AI racers have a personal vendetta against you and will ruin your day with perfectly-timed red shells.

If your kid is used to Mario Kart 8 Deluxe with its gorgeous HD tracks and smooth drifting, this will feel like going from a Tesla to a go-kart with square wheels. That said, there's something genuinely valuable about showing kids where their favorite games came from—and teaching them that fun doesn't require cutting-edge graphics.

This is a "special occasion" game, not an everyday driver. Break it out for retro game night, use it to teach gaming history, or bond over split-screen chaos. Just don't expect it to compete with modern titles for their attention span.

Age Fit

Best for kids 6-12 who either have nostalgia-driven parents or genuinely appreciate retro gaming. Younger kids will struggle with the controls; older kids will likely find it too dated unless they're retro gaming enthusiasts.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

88

Colorful, cartoonish racing with beloved Nintendo characters. Competition is friendly and playful—you throw shells and banana peels, not punches. No dialogue means no language concerns. The tone is upbeat and family-friendly throughout, modeling good sportsmanship in a lighthearted way.

Imaginative

92

Groundbreaking for its time—literally invented the kart racing genre. The Mode 7 graphics were revolutionary in 1992, creating a pseudo-3D racing experience. Creative power-up system (shells, bananas, lightning bolts) that inspired decades of imitators. Each track has distinct themes and obstacles that reward exploration and experimentation with racing lines.

Safe

95

Zero predatory monetization (no IAP, no loot boxes). Local multiplayer only means no online chat or stranger danger. No violence beyond cartoonish bumping and spinning out. The gameplay loop is self-contained—you race, you finish, you're done. No compulsive hooks or infinite scrolling mechanics. About as safe as retro gaming gets.

Enriching

72

Builds hand-eye coordination, spatial reasoning, and strategic thinking (when to use items, optimal racing lines). Teaches persistence through repeated attempts to master tracks. Split-screen multiplayer fosters social skills and turn-taking. However, it's fundamentally arcade racing—not particularly deep in terms of cognitive growth or meaningful life lessons. Entertainment value is high, enrichment is moderate.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Zero modern gaming toxicity: no ads, no IAP, no chat, no internet required—just pure racing
Split-screen multiplayer teaches turn-taking and gracious losing (or gloating, depending on your household)
Builds genuine problem-solving skills as kids learn track shortcuts and power-up timing
Nostalgia bomb for parents who can actually share their childhood gaming experience
The difficulty curve means kids have to earn their wins—no participation trophies here

⚠

What to Watch For

Graphics are seriously dated—we're talking pixelated characters that look like blurry sprites, not the smooth 3D Mario Kart 8 kids expect today
Controls feel stiff and slippery compared to modern kart racers; expect some frustration during the learning curve
The AI is notoriously brutal—rubber-banding means you can dominate a race and get destroyed by a shell in the final seconds
No online play means this only works if you have someone physically present to race with
Battle Mode can get competitive between siblings—monitor for rage-quitting and controller-throwing

Conversation Starters

"Which power-up do you think is most fair? Should someone in first place get hit by lightning from someone in last?"
"What's more frustrating: getting hit by a shell right before the finish line, or slipping on a banana you didn't see?"
"If you could design a new Mario Kart track, what would it look like?"
"Why do you think this game from 1992 is still fun even though the graphics look so old?"
"Is it more satisfying to win because you're the best racer, or because you used items perfectly?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic