This is a genuinely good book that does one thing exceptionally well: helping kids understand grief. Henkes doesn't sugarcoat or overdramatize—he just sits with the feelings and shows a family working through loss together.
The problem? It's incredibly specific. Unless your kid is dealing with a grandparent's death (or you're preparing them for it), this book will feel slow and sad for no payoff. It's not a 'fun read'—it's medicine that tastes pretty good when you need it.
The 1998 publication shows. Modern middle-grade readers are used to faster pacing, more humor, more external plot. This is all internal processing. Valuable? Absolutely. Entertaining for a random Tuesday? Not really.
Bottom line: Keep this on your radar for when you need it. When that moment comes, you'll be grateful it exists. But don't expect kids to pick it up for pleasure reading.






