Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Stardust is one of those mid-2000s fantasy films that flew under the radar but has quietly built a devoted following. It's got Neil Gaiman's fingerprints all over it—whimsical, romantic, a little dark, genuinely imaginative.

The good: The world-building is excellent, the cast is having a blast, and there's real heart underneath the fantasy trappings. Robert De Niro's flamboyant pirate captain is a joy, and the central romance actually works. Themes about growing up and finding your true self land well.

The real talk: This is almost 20 years old now, and it shows. The pacing is leisurely—this is a two-hour fairy tale that meanders through its plot rather than racing. Kids raised on MCU-speed editing may get restless. The effects are mostly solid but occasionally dated. And while the violence is fantasy-level, the witches are genuinely menacing in ways that might spook younger viewers.

It's rated for 12+ by Common Sense Media, which feels right. This isn't a little-kid movie—there's peril, some scary imagery, romantic content, and mild innuendo. But for tweens and teens who can handle a slower pace and appreciate a well-crafted fairy tale? This is a gem worth discovering. Just set expectations that it's not a Marvel movie.

Age Fit

Best for ages 10-12 and up who can handle moderate fantasy peril, some scary witch imagery, and romantic storylines. The 2007 pacing and storybook tone may feel slow to younger kids expecting non-stop action. Adults who enjoy fantasy romance will find plenty to love here.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

78

A romantic fairy tale adventure with positive themes of keeping promises, personal growth, and true love. Models courage and loyalty through Tristan's quest. Some sword fighting and magical violence, but handled with a fantastical, storybook tone rather than gritty realism. Romance is sweet rather than overtly sexual. Pacing is solid if occasionally slow for modern tastes.

Imaginative

85

High marks for originality and world-building—a magical realm beyond a wall in Victorian England, fallen stars that become people, sky pirates, witches seeking immortality. The Neil Gaiman source material brings genuine creativity and whimsy. Invites viewers into a richly imagined fantasy world with its own rules and logic. Visually inventive with practical and CGI effects that still hold up reasonably well.

Safe

68

Common Sense Media rates it 12+, which tracks. Some moderate fantasy violence (sword fights, magical attacks), a scene where a witch cuts out a star's heart (though not graphically shown), implied sexuality (cross-dressing captain's reveal, some innuendo), and occasional mild language. The villain witches are genuinely menacing and there are a few jump-scare moments. Not suitable for sensitive younger kids, but no gratuitous gore or explicit content. The surprise factor is moderate—parents should expect PG-13 level content.

Enriching

72

Themes of self-discovery, keeping one's word, and recognizing true love versus infatuation offer solid takeaways. Tristan's journey from naive boy to confident man provides a classic hero's journey arc. The story explores sacrifice, mortality, and what makes life meaningful. Michelle Pfeiffer's witch seeking eternal youth raises questions about vanity and aging. Entertaining throughout with humor, romance, and adventure, though not particularly deep or challenging intellectually.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuinely imaginative world-building that feels fresh even now—a Victorian village bordering a magical realm with its own bizarre rules
Strong themes about growing up, keeping promises, and learning what real love looks like (spoiler: not the shallow girl he starts out chasing)
Robert De Niro as a cross-dressing sky pirate captain is unexpectedly delightful and adds LGBTQ+ representation in a fun, affirming way
Michelle Pfeiffer chews scenery as the villain witch, and the ensemble cast (Claire Danes, Charlie Cox, Mark Strong) all commit fully
High audience scores (86% RT, 7.6 IMDb) suggest this resonates more than critics initially gave it credit for

⚠

What to Watch For

Fantasy violence including sword fights and a scene where a witch attempts to cut out a star's heart (not shown graphically but the intent is clear)
Some genuinely scary moments—the witches are menacing, there's a ghost subplot, and younger kids may find it intense
Mild sexual innuendo and romantic content appropriate for tweens but not little kids
Pacing is leisurely by 2025 standards—this is a 2-hour fairy tale that takes its time, which may test the patience of kids raised on Marvel

Conversation Starters

"Tristan starts out chasing Victoria but ends up falling for Yvaine. What do you think changed? Have you ever thought you wanted something and then realized you actually wanted something different?"
"The witches want to live forever by stealing youth. If you could live forever, would you want to? What would be good or bad about it?"
"Captain Shakespeare hides who he really is because he's afraid his crew won't accept him. Have you ever felt like you had to hide part of yourself? How did that feel?"
"The star (Yvaine) loses her glow when she's sad or scared. Do you think that's true for people too—that our 'light' shows how we feel inside?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic