Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Six of Crows is one of those rare YA books that actually deserves its hype. Bardugo crafts a genuinely clever heist story with characters who feel real—flawed, traumatized, and trying to survive in a world that's been brutal to them. The Ketterdam setting is richly imagined, and the magic system adds flavor without overwhelming the plot.
But let's be clear: this is not for younger teens. The content is consistently mature—violence, references to sex trafficking and prostitution, organized crime, and characters dealing with serious trauma. It's not gratuitous, but it's present throughout. Common Sense Media parents are right to flag the dark themes.
For readers 14+ who can handle morally gray characters and a darker tone, this is excellent. The representation is solid (disability, diverse cast), the writing is sharp, and it's genuinely hard to put down. Just don't hand it to your 11-year-old because they finished Harry Potter and want 'more fantasy.'
Age Fit
This is mature YA best suited for readers 14 and up who can handle darker themes and moral complexity. The violence, crime setting, and references to exploitation make it inappropriate for middle schoolers, despite some 12-13 year olds claiming they loved it. Older teens and adults will appreciate the sophisticated plotting and character work.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
58
The story centers on six morally gray criminals pulling off a heist, with themes of revenge, survival, and redemption. Characters show loyalty and cooperation under pressure, but the setting involves organized crime, casinos, and the criminal underworld. Backstories include trauma, violence, and exploitation. The emotional tone is darker than typical YA, though relationships between crew members do model trust and found-family dynamics.
Imaginative
88
Bardugo builds a richly detailed fantasy world in Ketterdam—a gritty, Amsterdam-inspired trading hub with a unique magic system (Grisha powers), intricate heist plotting, and complex character backstories. The impossible-heist premise invites readers into creative problem-solving and world-building that feels fresh within YA fantasy. The magic system is woven into character abilities rather than driving plot mechanically, which adds depth.
Safe
62
This book contains mature content that would surprise younger readers: violence (including torture and death), references to prostitution and human trafficking, gambling, substance use, and some sexual tension. Language includes occasional profanity. Common Sense Media parent reviews confirm 'dark themes' and 'adult themes' including crime and complex dynamics. It's not graphic or explicit, but the content is consistently mature. For readers 14+ who know what they're getting into, it's manageable; for younger readers stumbling upon it, it could be jarring.
Enriching
79
The book explores complex themes of trauma, survival, loyalty, and moral ambiguity. Each character grapples with their past and questions of identity, revenge versus justice, and what they're willing to sacrifice. The heist structure requires strategic thinking, and the diverse cast (including disabled representation with Kaz's mobility issues) offers multiple perspectives. It's genuinely entertaining with sharp plotting and wit, while also prompting reflection on ethics, power, and belonging.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Genuinely clever heist plotting with twists that land—this isn't paint-by-numbers YA
Six distinct, flawed characters with real trauma and growth arcs that make you actually care about them
World-building that feels lived-in and gritty, not just a generic fantasy backdrop
Disability representation (Kaz uses a cane) integrated naturally into character without being preachy
Sharp dialogue and dark humor that respects teen readers' intelligence
⚠
What to Watch For
Violence including torture, death, and physical assault—not gratuitous but definitely present
References to prostitution, human trafficking, and sexual exploitation as part of the world's criminal underworld
Morally ambiguous protagonists who steal, kill, and operate outside the law—no clear heroes here
Some language and sexual tension (no explicit scenes but definitely implied)
Dark backstories involving abuse and trauma that could be triggering
Conversation Starters
"Kaz and his crew aren't exactly heroes—do you think people can do bad things for good reasons? Where's the line?"
"Each character is running from something in their past. How do you think trauma shapes who they become?"
"The book shows a world where people are bought, sold, and exploited. Why do you think the author included those darker elements?"
"If you had to pull off an impossible heist, which of the six crew members' skills would you want on your team?"
"The characters form a kind of found family. What makes that different from a regular family?"
