Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Shadow and Bone delivers imaginative world-building with its Grisha magic system and Russian-inspired setting, which genuinely stands out in the crowded YA fantasy space. The problem? It's aggressively tropey—love triangles, Chosen One narratives, predictable plotting—and the romantic content worries parents for good reason.

Multiple parent reviews flag 'sexual imagery' and unhealthy relationship dynamics that feel inappropriate for younger teens. The Darkling's manipulative behavior toward Alina isn't just villain stuff; it's romanticized in ways that model terrible relationship patterns. If your kid is 15+ and has read plenty of YA, they'll navigate it fine. But if you're thinking about your 12-year-old who loved Percy Jackson, pump the brakes.

The other issue: quality is divisive. Fans are passionate, but plenty of readers find the first half 'actually terrible' (Goodreads' words, not mine) and only tolerable because the second half improves. It's entertaining enough if you're in the target zone, but it's not enriching literature. It's fantasy junk food—tasty for some, but not particularly nourishing.

Age Fit

Best for 15+ despite being marketed as YA. The sexual content, relationship dynamics, and mature themes make it a poor fit for middle schoolers, though mature 13-14 year olds who've read similar content might be okay. Definitely not for the 11-12 crowd despite the fantasy adventure premise.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

62

The trilogy models some positive traits like friendship and courage, but parent reviews consistently flag problematic relationship dynamics and sexual content that undermines emotional health for younger readers. The 'love' storylines include concerning power imbalances and unhealthy romantic patterns typical of YA fantasy. Pacing is reasonable but the emotional tone skews toward manipulation and toxic relationships rather than healthy modeling.

Imaginative

78

Bardugo creates a genuinely unique magic system (Grisha powers) set in a Russian-inspired fantasy world that stands out from typical medieval European settings. The world-building is detailed and invites readers to explore the mythology of the Fold, the different Grisha orders, and political intrigue. However, Reddit reviews note it 'hits almost every YA trope,' which limits true originality in plot and character arcs.

Safe

58

Multiple parent reviews on Common Sense Media express concern about 'sexual imagery' and mature content that isn't appropriate for younger teens. There's violence (mild to moderate), death, and romantic/sexual content that would be unexpected for a 12-year-old picking this up. The book itself is safe from a platform perspective, but content-wise it pushes boundaries for the younger end of YA. Not graphic, but definitely not safe for middle-grade readers.

Enriching

65

There's some value in exploring themes of power, identity, and self-discovery as Alina grows from 'frightened girl' to leader. The political intrigue offers complexity beyond simple good-vs-evil. However, Goodreads reviews note the first half is 'actually terrible' and Reddit users who are 'over YA' found it unenjoyable. The predictable plot and heavy reliance on romance tropes limits deeper cognitive engagement. Entertainment value is mixed—fans love it, but it's divisive.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuinely creative magic system and Russian-inspired setting that breaks from generic medieval fantasy
Strong female protagonist who grows from powerless orphan to confident leader
Intricate political intrigue and world-building that rewards attention
Massive fanbase and Netflix adaptation mean built-in conversation potential with peers
Second half picks up significantly for readers who push through the slow start

⚠

What to Watch For

Sexual content and romantic imagery that multiple parents flag as inappropriate for younger teens
Unhealthy relationship dynamics and power imbalances in the romance plotlines
Violence including death, torture references, and battle scenes (not graphic but present)
Very slow first half that loses many readers before it gets good
Heavy YA tropes—if your kid is over love triangles and Chosen One narratives, this will feel tired

Conversation Starters

"Alina has to choose between two very different guys—what do you think makes a relationship healthy vs. unhealthy?"
"The Darkling has done terrible things but thinks it's for the greater good. When does 'the ends justify the means' actually work?"
"If you suddenly discovered you had a rare power, would you want to use it or hide it? Why?"
"The book is set in a Russia-inspired world. What real historical elements did you recognize?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Shadow And Bone Grishaverse? Put this WISE score on your site