Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Redwall is a middle-grade fantasy institution for good reason. It's got everything: a plucky underdog hero, a terrifying villain, epic battles, riddles, quests, and feasts so detailed you'll want to pause and make a trifle.

The violence is real—this is a siege story with swords, strategy, and sacrifice—but it's handled with the gravity and context of classic fantasy, not gratuitous or gory. Some kids will be ready at 8, others not until 10 or 11. If your child loved The Chronicles of Narnia or is ready for something meatier than Wings of Fire, this is the move.

The prose is dense and British, with dialect work that gives each species its own voice (vermin sound working-class, woodlanders more refined). It's old-school in pacing—published in 1986—but the world-building holds up beautifully. If your kid can commit to 300+ pages, they'll be rewarded with a story that's been beloved for nearly 40 years and spawned 21 sequels.

This is comfort food fantasy with real stakes. Highly recommended for the right reader.

Age Fit

Best for ages 10-14, though strong 8-9 year old readers can handle it if they're okay with battle scenes and some character deaths. The 22-book series has devoted fans well into adulthood, but the sweet spot is upper elementary through middle school.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

82

Models courage, friendship, and community defense against evil. The mice of Redwall Abbey work together, care for each other, and show genuine kindness. There's violence (it's a war story with medieval battles), but it's framed clearly as good vs. evil with emotional stakes. Some character deaths occur, which parents note as a concern for sensitive younger readers, but they're handled with gravity rather than gratuitousness. The tone is earnest and hopeful—think Lord of the Rings for the middle-grade set.

Imaginative

91

Mossflower Wood is richly realized—a complete medieval fantasy world populated entirely by animals with distinct cultures, dialects, and histories. Jacques creates elaborate feasts (the food descriptions are legendary), riddles, songs, and a mythology around Martin the Warrior that feels lived-in. The quest structure and world-building invite kids to imagine themselves in this universe. It's been inspiring fan art, role-play, and creative writing for decades. One of TIME's 100 Best Fantasy Books for good reason.

Safe

72

This is a war story with battle sequences, character deaths, and a villain (Cluny the Scourge) who is genuinely menacing. Violence is present but not graphic or gory—think swords, not splatter. The real concern is emotional intensity: kids who are sensitive to character death or peril may struggle. Common Sense Media parents recommend age 10+, noting it's not for all younger children. No sexual content, no profanity, no modern safety concerns (it's a book). The violence is the medieval-fantasy variety, clearly contextualized, but it's there.

Enriching

86

A classic hero's journey with a bumbling apprentice (Matthias) who grows into a warrior and leader. Themes of courage, sacrifice, community, and standing up to tyranny are woven throughout. The riddles and quest elements encourage problem-solving. The rich language and British dialect work (vermin speak differently than woodlanders) expose kids to linguistic variety. It's a gateway to Tolkien and other epic fantasy. Strong readers will be challenged and rewarded; it builds vocabulary and stamina for longer narratives.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

A complete, immersive fantasy world that's been hooking kids for 40 years—Mossflower Wood feels as real as Middle-earth
Matthias the mouse is a relatable hero: clumsy, earnest, and grows from bumbling apprentice to warrior through courage and friendship
The food descriptions are absurdly detailed and delightful—every feast is a multi-page sensory experience that will make you hungry
Gateway drug to epic fantasy: if your kid loves this, Tolkien and Lloyd Alexander are next
Strong themes of community, bravery, and standing up to bullies without being preachy

⚠

What to Watch For

Battle violence and character deaths—it's a war story, and some beloved characters don't make it. Not graphic, but emotionally intense for sensitive kids
Cluny the Scourge is a legitimately scary villain with nightmares and menace—younger or anxious readers may find him too much
Dense prose and British dialect (vermin speak in Cockney-ish slang)—this is a commitment read, best for confident readers who can handle 300+ pages
First published in 1986, so some pacing and style feels old-school compared to modern middle-grade fantasy

Conversation Starters

"Matthias starts out as kind of a mess—when have you felt like you weren't good enough for something, and how did you handle it?"
"The Redwallers have to decide whether to fight or hide. What would you do if your home was threatened?"
"Cluny is terrifying but also kind of tragic—do you think villains are born or made?"
"The riddles and clues to find Martin's sword are a big part of the story. What's the hardest puzzle you've ever solved?"
"If you lived in Mossflower Wood, would you be a mouse, a badger, a sparrow, or something else? What would your role be?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic