Pink and Say – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Pink and Say

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book1994

81%

WISE Score

4.8

Amazon

A gut-punch Civil War story about friendship, courage, and the cost of freedom—passed down through Patricia Polacco's own family.

Pink and Say

book

1994

81%

WISE Score

4.8

Amazon

A gut-punch Civil War story about friendship, courage, and the cost of freedom—passed down through Patricia Polacco's own family.

4.8

Jump to

Also rated on

4.8

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is one of those books that punches you right in the heart and doesn't let go. Patricia Polacco tells her great-great-grandfather's true Civil War story with unflinching honesty—there's friendship, courage, and profound kindness, but also death, violence, and the brutal reality of war.

It's not an easy read. Pink dies. Kids will cry. But that's also why it matters. This book teaches empathy and history in a way that textbooks never could, connecting kids to real people who lived through America's most painful chapter.

The 4.8 Amazon rating and widespread classroom use speak to its power, but parents should know this isn't a bedtime story for sensitive 5-year-olds despite some marketing suggesting K-3. This is really an 8-12 book that benefits enormously from adult guidance to process the heavy themes.

If your kid is ready for emotionally complex historical fiction that doesn't sugarcoat the past, this is essential reading. Just have tissues ready.

Age Fit

Best for ages 8-13, though mature 7-year-olds can handle it with support. The emotional intensity and themes of death make it too heavy for most younger kids. Upper elementary and middle schoolers will get the most from the historical and moral complexity.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Models profound kindness, courage, and cross-racial friendship during the Civil War. Moe Moe Bay's compassion and the bond between Pink and Sheldon demonstrate selflessness and shared humanity. Emotionally heavy but age-appropriate for the target audience, with themes of sacrifice and moral courage that resonate without being gratuitous.

Imaginative

Patricia Polacco's distinctive illustrated style brings the story to life visually. The narrative structure—a family story passed down through generations—invites kids to think about their own family histories. However, this is primarily a historical narrative rather than a world-building or creative-play story, so imagination is sparked more through empathy and historical connection than through fantastical elements.

Safe

This is a Civil War story with war wounds, death (Pink is ultimately hanged by Confederate troops), and the trauma of slavery and violence. While handled with care and age-appropriately for the 8-12 range, it's emotionally intense and contains themes of mortality and racial violence that could be distressing for younger or more sensitive readers. Not a 'surprise' given the historical context, but definitely requires preparation.

Enriching

Exceptional historical and emotional education. Kids learn about the Civil War, the Underground Railroad era, racial dynamics, and moral courage through a deeply personal lens. The story builds empathy, teaches about sacrifice, and connects readers to real American history through a family narrative. The 'Kindness Edition' includes discussion questions that extend learning. This is the kind of book that stays with readers for life.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

True family story that makes the Civil War deeply personal and real—kids connect to history through actual people
Models extraordinary kindness and cross-racial friendship during America's darkest chapter
Polacco's illustrations are gorgeous and bring emotional depth without being graphic
Teaches about sacrifice, moral courage, and the reality that not all stories have happy endings
The 'Kindness Edition' includes discussion questions perfect for classroom or family conversations

⚠

What to Watch For

This is heavy—Pink is ultimately hanged by Confederate troops, and the ending will make kids (and adults) cry
Themes of war wounds, slavery, and racial violence are handled carefully but are still intense for sensitive kids
Best read with an adult who can help process the emotional weight and historical context
Some kids under 8 might find it too sad or scary, even though it's technically marketed down to kindergarten

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Moe Moe Bay risked her life to help Sheldon, even though she didn't know him?"
"What would it have been like to be a kid during the Civil War? How is that different from your life?"
"Pink and Sheldon were on the same side but came from very different backgrounds. How did that affect their friendship?"
"The story talks about Pink getting to shake Abraham Lincoln's hand. Why was that so meaningful to him?"
"This story was passed down through Patricia Polacco's family. What stories have been passed down in our family?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic