Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Nonnas has its heart in the right place—a son honoring his late mother by opening an Italian restaurant with real grandmas cooking is objectively charming. The themes of grief, family legacy, and intergenerational connection are genuinely wholesome and enriching.

But here's the thing: the reviews suggest this is more 'pleasant background viewing' than 'memorable family film night.' Critics liked it (82% RT), but audiences were more lukewarm (72% RT, 6.8 IMDb), and Metacritic's 57 suggests it's solidly mediocre. That Letterboxd 3.2/5 is particularly telling—film enthusiasts found it just okay.

It's perfectly safe and sweet, but probably won't blow anyone away. If your family loves food culture, Italian heritage, or you're specifically looking for something to watch with kids processing grief, this could hit the spot. Otherwise, it's a 'sure, if it's already on' rather than 'drop everything and watch this.' The WISE fundamentals are solid, but the entertainment execution seems to be just... fine.

Age Fit

Best for ages 10-14 who can handle grief themes and appreciate slower-paced, heartfelt stories. Older teens might find it too sentimental, younger kids might get bored or need the death theme explained.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

82

A heartwarming premise centered on honoring a deceased mother through food and intergenerational connection. The concept of bringing grandmothers together as chefs inherently models respect for elders, family bonds, and cultural heritage. Common Sense Media rated it appropriate for 10+, suggesting emotionally healthy content without inappropriate themes. The film appears to focus on grief, perseverance, and community—all wholesome themes when handled well.

Imaginative

58

The premise is sweet but fairly conventional—underdog restaurant story meets tribute to mom. It's not breaking new ground narratively. The inclusion of actual nonnas as chefs adds a charming cultural authenticity angle, but the overall concept feels like familiar feel-good territory rather than truly imaginative storytelling. It may inspire appreciation for Italian culture and cooking, but won't likely spark creative thinking or exploration in the way more inventive films do.

Safe

88

Common Sense Media's age 10 rating suggests mild content at most. The synopsis indicates themes of grief and loss (deceased mother), which could be emotionally heavy for younger viewers but isn't unexpected given the premise. No indicators of violence, scary content, inappropriate language, or sexual content. The restaurant-opening storyline and grandmother chefs setup suggests this is a straightforward drama without surprise disturbing elements. Grief is handled in a predictable, purposeful way rather than as shock content.

Enriching

70

The film offers meaningful themes around grief, honoring family legacy, risk-taking, and cultural heritage. The intergenerational aspect—young man working with elderly Italian grandmothers—provides opportunities for empathy and understanding across age groups. It models entrepreneurship and following your dreams despite obstacles. However, with mixed reviews (Metacritic 57, Letterboxd 3.2/5), it may not execute these themes in a particularly compelling or memorable way. The entertainment value seems moderate based on audience scores (RT 72%, IMDb 6.8).

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuinely sweet premise about honoring family and cultural heritage through food
Intergenerational connection—kids see a young adult working with and learning from elderly women
Models healthy grief processing and channeling loss into meaningful action
Celebrates Italian culture and the value of traditional cooking and family recipes
No inappropriate content—safe family viewing for ages 10+

⚠

What to Watch For

The entire premise hinges on the main character's mother dying—needs a heads-up for kids sensitive to death/loss themes
Mixed reviews suggest the execution might be more saccharine than substantial—could feel slow or overly sentimental
At 6.8/10 on IMDb and 3.2/5 on Letterboxd, this is 'fine' rather than must-see—manage expectations
May work better for families who love food/cooking shows and cultural stories than action-oriented kids

Conversation Starters

"What's something special you'd want to do to remember someone you love?"
"Have you ever tried to cook something that reminded you of a family member? What was it?"
"The main character takes a big risk opening a restaurant—when is it worth taking a big risk for something you believe in?"
"What do the nonnas (grandmas) bring to the restaurant that younger chefs might not?"
"If you could open any kind of restaurant or business, what would it be and why?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Nonnas? Put this WISE score on your site