Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the truth: National Velvet is a beloved classic with a genuinely inspiring underdog story, but it's a tough sell for modern kids. The 1935 prose style isn't just 'vintage charm'—multiple parents report struggling to get through the first chapter, and Common Sense Media specifically notes the shorthand dialogue could be difficult even for strong readers.

The bones are good: Velvet's determination, her supportive family, the thrill of breaking gender barriers in horse racing. But one parent reviewer specifically flags 'objectionable content' that surprised them, likely period attitudes that haven't aged well.

This is really for the horse-obsessed kid who's already plowed through every modern horse book and is hungry for classics, or for families who enjoy reading challenging historical literature together and can talk through the dated elements. For everyone else? The Elizabeth Taylor movie might be the better entry point.

The 4.7 Amazon rating shows it still has fans, but that's mostly adults remembering childhood nostalgia. Be honest about whether your kid has the patience and reading stamina for this one—there are more accessible ways to get the 'girl and her horse chase the impossible dream' story in 2025.

Age Fit

Best for confident readers 10-14 who are already passionate about horses and willing to work through vintage prose. Younger kids will struggle with the writing style, and older teens will likely find it too dated unless they're specifically into classic literature or equestrian history.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

82

A heartwarming story of determination, family support, and pursuing dreams against the odds. The close-knit Brown family dynamic is warm and supportive, with Velvet's mother and siblings rallying around her ambition. The bond between Velvet and her horse is tender and earnest. However, the shorthand dialogue style and British idioms from the 1930s can feel distant and may not resonate emotionally with modern readers as strongly as contemporary stories.

Imaginative

75

The premise of a 14-year-old girl defying gender barriers to compete in the Grand National is genuinely inspiring and imaginative for its 1935 publication. The atmospheric portrait of rural England between the World Wars offers a window into another time and place. However, the book doesn't particularly invite creative expression or exploration beyond the linear narrative—it's a classic underdog story told straight, without the inventive world-building or playful elements that spark young imaginations today.

Safe

65

Common Sense Media notes the book contains some objectionable content that surprised at least one parent reviewer. The Sonrise Stable review specifically flags 'objectionable content' that makes it 'not appropriate for children' in their assessment. While details aren't fully specified in the search results, this is a 1935 novel with period attitudes. The shorthand dialogue can be confusing for young readers. Multiple parent reviews mention difficulty getting through the first chapter, suggesting accessibility issues. No graphic violence or explicit content, but the vintage writing style and potential period-appropriate attitudes warrant caution.

Enriching

78

The story models perseverance, dedication, and the courage to challenge societal expectations—Velvet trains relentlessly and becomes the first woman to compete in the Grand National. Themes of following your dreams despite being 'skinny and frail' with limited resources offer genuine inspiration. The historical setting provides educational value about interwar Britain and horse racing culture. However, entertainment value is diminished by the dated prose style—multiple parents report struggling to get through it, and Common Sense Media notes the 'unusual' shorthand dialogue could be 'difficult to follow for very young readers.'

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Velvet's underdog story is genuinely inspiring—a skinny, frail 14-year-old girl becomes the first woman to compete in the Grand National on a raffle-won horse
Models serious dedication and work ethic: she trains daily and whispers dreams to her horse, showing what commitment looks like
The warm, supportive Brown family dynamic is lovely—they rally around Velvet's 'breathtaking piece of folly' rather than shutting her down
Historical window into rural England between the World Wars, plus horse racing culture
For true horse-obsessed kids, the equestrian details and racing scenes can be thrilling

⚠

What to Watch For

The shorthand dialogue and 1930s British idioms are genuinely confusing—multiple parents report struggling to get through even the first chapter
At least one detailed parent review flags 'objectionable content' that makes it 'not appropriate for children'—likely period-appropriate attitudes or language that don't translate well
This is a 1935 novel that reads like a 1935 novel—the pacing, prose style, and cultural references feel distant to modern kids
Best for strong, patient readers who already love classic horse stories; reluctant readers will bounce off this hard

Conversation Starters

"Velvet's mom calls her dream 'breathtaking folly' but still supports her. When have you wanted to try something that seemed impossible?"
"No woman had ever competed in the Grand National before Velvet. What would it feel like to be the absolute first at something?"
"Velvet won her horse in a raffle and trained him herself. Do you think talent matters more than having fancy equipment or training?"
"The story takes place in 1930s England when girls weren't expected to do things like race horses. What things do people your age do now that would have been shocking back then?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic