Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the real deal—a beautifully crafted, award-winning introduction to Harriet Tubman that doesn't talk down to kids or sugarcoat history. The lyrical writing and Kadir Nelson's powerful illustrations make this more than just a biography; it's almost mythic in scope.
The spiritual framing (God's voice guiding Tubman north) is central and handled with deep reverence. If your family isn't religious, it might feel heavy-handed, but it's also historically accurate to how Tubman herself understood her mission.
The book doesn't shy away from slavery's brutality—there's fear, pain, and real danger—but it's age-appropriate and necessary to understand what Tubman overcame. This is the kind of book that sticks with kids, the kind that builds both historical literacy and moral courage. Highly recommended for elementary-age readers ready to engage with serious history.
Age Fit
Best for ages 6-12. The poetic text and serious subject matter work well for early elementary through middle school. Younger kids can appreciate it as a read-aloud with parent guidance; older kids can grapple with the historical and moral complexity independently.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Deeply reverent portrayal of courage, faith, and compassion. Models perseverance and selflessness through Tubman's heroic actions. Does depict the harsh realities of slavery (fear of whippings, being sold, bleeding feet) but handles them with appropriate gravity for the subject matter. The spiritual journey and reliance on faith provide emotional grounding.
Imaginative
82
Lyrical, poetic text that weaves Tubman's literal journey with her spiritual experience of hearing God's voice. The narrative device of divine guidance creates a transcendent quality. Kadir Nelson's illustrations (Caldecott Honor) are known for their powerful, evocative artistry. Less about sparking creative play, more about expanding historical and spiritual imagination.
Safe
75
Age-appropriate depiction of slavery's brutality—pain, danger, fear of violence are present but not graphic. Bleeding feet and the constant threat of being caught create tension. Common Sense Media notes Harriet is 'in pain and danger throughout.' These are historically accurate and necessary to understand the stakes, but younger or sensitive kids might find them distressing. No surprise content for a book about slavery and escape.
Enriching
93
Exceptional historical and moral education. Introduces young readers to one of America's most important freedom fighters. The emphasis on faith, courage, and helping others (300+ people led to freedom) provides powerful character lessons. Caldecott Honor and Coretta Scott King Award winner. Creates empathy and understanding of a brutal period while celebrating human resilience and heroism.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Caldecott Honor and Coretta Scott King Award winner with stunning illustrations
Introduces one of history's most important heroes in an age-appropriate, lyrical way
Emphasizes faith, courage, and selflessness—Tubman risked everything to lead 300+ people to freedom
Poetic text elevates the story beyond simple biography into something transcendent
Doesn't sanitize slavery but handles the harsh realities with appropriate gravity for young readers
⚠
What to Watch For
Depicts the real dangers and pain of slavery—fear of whippings, being sold, bleeding feet during escape
Strong religious themes throughout (God's voice guiding Tubman); this is central to the narrative
Younger or sensitive kids might find the tension and danger distressing
Tubman leaves her husband and family behind in this first escape—a complex, painful choice worth discussing
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think Harriet heard God's voice telling her to be free? What does freedom mean?"
"How scared would you be to escape through the woods at night, not knowing if you'd make it?"
"Harriet went back 19 times to help other people escape. Would you go back into danger to help others?"
"Why do you think people called her Moses? (Hint: Moses led people out of slavery in the Bible too)"
