Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is the kind of middle grade book that does everything right without being annoying about it. Magnolia is a genuinely likable protagonist who feels real—she's overlooked, a bit lonely, but resourceful and curious rather than mopey. The sock detective premise could've been cutesy and twee, but Miller makes it work as an actual adventure through NYC that introduces kids to the idea that every person and every lost object has a story.

The Newbery Honor is well-deserved. This isn't just eating your vegetables; it's legitimately entertaining while building empathy and celebrating urban diversity. Yes, it touches on harder topics like racism and abuse, but reviews consistently note these are handled appropriately for the age group—they're teaching moments, not trauma dumps.

If you've got an 8-12 year old who likes mysteries, friendship stories, or just needs something with more depth than Diary of a Wimpy Kid but isn't ready for full YA, this is a solid pick. It's modern, it's got heart, and kids will actually want to read it.

Age Fit

Ideal for 8-12 year olds who are ready for illustrated middle grade fiction with some substance. The mystery hook works for reluctant readers, while the themes of belonging and community give more confident readers something to chew on. Probably too young for most teens unless they're reading it with a younger sibling.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

88

A warm-hearted story about friendship, community, and belonging that models kindness and curiosity. Magnolia's journey from feeling invisible to finding connection through her sock detective work is emotionally healthy and age-appropriate. The book gently addresses real issues like feeling overlooked and finding your place, while maintaining an optimistic, cooperative tone throughout.

Imaginative

82

The premise of a 10-year-old sock detective solving the mystery of lost laundromat socks is genuinely creative and whimsical. The adventure across NYC meeting diverse characters invites curiosity about urban communities and the stories behind everyday objects. Miller's background as an artist shows through in the illustrated format, though the concept is more charming than groundbreaking.

Safe

78

Generally very safe for the target age group, though one review notes 'mild triggers with some racist acts and talk of abuse.' These appear to be handled age-appropriately as teachable moments within the story rather than graphic content. No other concerning content flagged across multiple parent reviews. The difficult topics are present but contextually appropriate for middle grade readers learning about real-world issues.

Enriching

85

Multiple reviews highlight 'easily digestible lessons' and note that it 'showcases the diversity that makes a small community within a large city wonderful.' The book builds empathy through encounters with different people and perspectives, teaches persistence and problem-solving, and explores themes of community connection. The Newbery Honor recognition signals literary merit. Entertaining mystery structure keeps it engaging while delivering meaningful takeaways about boldness, friendship, and seeing others.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Newbery Honor winner that's actually fun to read—mystery structure keeps pages turning while sneaking in real lessons about community and connection
Celebrates NYC's diversity through Magnolia's adventures meeting pizzeria owners, deli workers, and plant store employees, each with their own story
Perfect bridge between chapter books and full novels with illustrations that support but don't dominate the story
Models a kid taking initiative and being bold enough to venture into the unknown, which is genuinely empowering without being preachy
Written by Chanel Miller (yes, that Chanel Miller) who brings an artist's sensibility to storytelling—the book has heart and visual appeal

⚠

What to Watch For

Does touch on racism and abuse in age-appropriate ways—these aren't graphic but are present as real-world issues the characters encounter
Magnolia starts the story feeling invisible and overlooked, which might resonate deeply (in a good way) with kids who feel similarly
The NYC setting is specific and loving—kids from small towns or suburbs might need a bit of context about laundromat culture and urban neighborhoods

Conversation Starters

"Have you ever felt invisible like Magnolia does at the start? What helped you feel more seen?"
"Why do you think nobody came back for their socks? What would make someone forget about something?"
"Magnolia meets all these different people in her neighborhood—who in our community do we see regularly but maybe don't really know?"
"What mystery would you want to solve in our neighborhood? What would you need to be brave enough to do?"
"The book shows some people being unkind because of how others look or where they're from. Why do you think that happens?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Magnolia Wu Unfolds it All