Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

King of Scars is solid, mature YA fantasy that doesn't pull punches. Bardugo's strength has always been world-building and morally complex characters, and Nikolai delivers on both fronts—he's charming, damaged, and genuinely trying to be a good king while literally possessed by dark magic. It's a great metaphor for PTSD and leadership under pressure.

That said, this is definitely on the darker end of YA. The drug addiction, rape-pregnancy subplot, and religious warfare aren't gratuitous, but they're present and handled with weight. If your teen loved Six of Crows, they can handle this. If they're just dipping their toes into YA fantasy, maybe start elsewhere.

The pacing is slower than Six of Crows—more political maneuvering, less heist action—and it's clearly book one of a duology, so not everything wraps up. Fans don't seem to mind (4.6 stars on Amazon), but know what you're getting into. This is for readers who want to sink into a complex fantasy world and don't need instant gratification.

Bottom line: Strong choice for older teens who want fantasy with substance, but definitely read the content warnings first.

Age Fit

Best for ages 15-18 who can handle mature themes and complex political fantasy. The dark content (violence, trauma, sexual situations) and sophisticated political intrigue make this too heavy for middle schoolers, but older teens who loved Six of Crows will eat it up. Adults who enjoy YA fantasy will find plenty to appreciate too.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

68

Models resilience, political responsibility, and friendship through Nikolai's journey as a young king facing internal demons and external threats. The narrative emphasizes cooperation and loyalty, though the darker themes (civil war aftermath, possession by dark magic, religious warfare) and mature content (drug addiction, rape-pregnancy subplot, implied sexual scenes) create emotional weight that's not universally age-appropriate. Characters demonstrate growth and moral complexity, but the tone skews mature rather than gentle.

Imaginative

82

Bardugo's Grishaverse is richly detailed with Slavic folklore influences, a complex magic system (Grisha powers), and political intrigue that invites readers into a fully-realized fantasy world. The dual narrative structure (Nikolai's demon-hunting quest and Nina's separate plotline) creates layered storytelling. Common Sense Media notes 'edgy and engaging characters' and the book delivers on world-building that fans consistently praise. Less focused on creative problem-solving than Six of Crows, but still imaginatively robust.

Safe

58

Contains significant mature content that makes it unsuitable for younger readers: drug addiction, rape resulting in pregnancy (not explicit but present), religious warfare, bloody violence from civil war, implied sexual scenes, and dark magical possession themes. Common Sense Media user reviews specifically flag these elements. While not gratuitous, these are serious adult themes that could be triggering or inappropriate for tweens and early teens. The book won't surprise YA readers familiar with Bardugo's work, but it's definitely on the mature end of the YA spectrum.

Enriching

76

Explores complex themes of leadership, trauma, identity, and the consequences of war. Nikolai's struggle with literal inner demons serves as metaphor for PTSD and the weight of responsibility. The political intrigue teaches about governance, diplomacy, and difficult choices. Nina's storyline addresses grief and purpose. The book doesn't shy away from showing how war affects civilians and the long recovery process. Strong character development and moral complexity, though entertainment sometimes takes backseat to setup for the duology's second book.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Bardugo's Grishaverse remains one of the most compelling YA fantasy worlds, with Slavic folklore, intricate magic systems, and political intrigue that doesn't talk down to readers
Nikolai is a charismatic, complex protagonist dealing with PTSD and leadership in ways that feel authentic—he's charming but genuinely struggling
Explores serious consequences of war, including how nations rebuild, how trauma manifests, and the cost of power—rare depth for YA fantasy
Nina's parallel storyline adds emotional weight and expands the world beyond one character's journey
Strong 4.6 Amazon rating and dedicated fanbase suggest this delivers for readers who want meaty, character-driven fantasy

⚠

What to Watch For

This is mature YA: drug addiction, a rape-pregnancy subplot (not explicit but present), religious warfare, and bloody violence from civil war—definitely 15+ territory
Implied sexual content and romantic tension that's more adult than middle-grade fantasy
Pacing is slower and more political than the action-packed Six of Crows duology—setup for book two means not all threads resolve
Dark magic possession and psychological horror elements may be intense for sensitive readers
Requires familiarity with the Grishaverse to fully appreciate—newcomers should start with Shadow and Bone or Six of Crows

Conversation Starters

"Nikolai keeps his trauma secret because he's king—do you think leaders should be more open about their struggles, or does that make them seem weak?"
"The book shows how countries recover after civil war. What do you think is harder: winning a war or rebuilding after one?"
"Nina is dealing with grief while trying to find new purpose. How do you think people figure out who they are after major loss?"
"The 'demon' inside Nikolai could be a metaphor for PTSD or addiction. What do you think the book is saying about facing your inner demons versus running from them?"
"Religion plays a complicated role in this story, sometimes helping and sometimes causing conflict. What makes religious belief helpful versus harmful in the book?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

King of Scars: King of Scars Duology, Book 1 Leigh Bardugo