2014
WISE Score
Amazon
Criminal Minds meets The Breakfast Club, but with significantly more serial killers and fewer detention snacks.
4.4
4.4View →Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)
Jennifer Lynn Barnes knows exactly how to write a hook. This isn't 'brain rot' YA; it's a sharp, fast-moving thriller that actually makes kids think about human behavior and logic.
It’s a solid 2014 title that hasn't lost its edge. If you have a teen who is bored by standard school reading, hand them this. It’s engaging, smart, and just the right amount of creepy.
Best for ages 13 or 14 and up. If your kid is into true crime podcasts or shows like Sherlock, they'll fly through this. It's too dark for the middle-school crowd, but perfect for high schoolers who want a smart mystery.
While it's a dark thriller about serial killers, the core is built on a 'found family' of gifted teens looking out for each other. It models loyalty and high-stakes cooperation, even if the backdrop is a bit grisly.
The 'Naturals' concept—teens with innate psychological profiling skills—is a clever hook. It invites readers to look at human behavior like a puzzle and keeps the 'who-done-it' guessing game sharp.
It's safe for the intended teen audience, but the subject matter is heavy. We're talking copycat killers and psychological trauma. There's some mild language and teen romance, but nothing that will catch a 14-year-old off guard.
This is basically a logic and psychology masterclass disguised as a YA novel. It encourages deductive reasoning and empathy by forcing the characters (and readers) to understand why people do what they do.
Jennifer Lynn Barnes is currently the reigning queen of the "genius teens in over their heads" genre, but Killer Instinct is where she really refined the formula. While the first book in the series spent a lot of time establishing the FBI’s "Naturals" program and the various "powers" (profiling, lie-detecting, pattern recognition), this sequel is where the emotional stakes finally catch up to the body count. It moves past the novelty of the premise and gets into the psychological grit that makes this series a perennial favorite for the "I'm bored with school reading" crowd.
The central hook here is a copycat killer mimicking the crimes of Dean’s father—a notorious incarcerated serial killer. This is a classic thriller trope, but Barnes uses it to do something more interesting than just provide a trail of breadcrumbs. It turns the investigation into a weapon used against the team.
In most YA mysteries, the "danger" feels like a plot device to keep the pages turning. Here, the friction feels internal. You’re watching these kids—who have been told their gifts make them special—realize that those same gifts make them targets. If you’re trying to gauge the real take on this teen serial killer thriller, know that the "killer" isn't just a monster in the woods; he’s a psychological mirror. It’s less about the gore and more about the manipulation.
If your teen found this series because they're obsessed with Barnes’ newer work, they’ll recognize the "puzzle-box" style of plotting. However, The Naturals is arguably more grounded than the Avery Grambs saga. There are fewer secret passages and more cold, hard logic.
This book is the bridge for kids who have outgrown the Nancy Drew or Hardy Boys phase but aren't quite ready for the nihilism of adult "Nordic Noir" or the heavy sexual content of adult procedurals. It’s the sweet spot for a reader who wants to be treated like an adult but still wants a story about people their own age. For those looking ahead, the stakes only get higher in the next installment, so it's worth checking out the real take on book three’s body count before they move on.
We’re living in a cultural moment where true crime is basically a personality trait. Killer Instinct taps into that without being exploitative. It treats the science of profiling with a level of respect that you don't usually see in teen fiction.
"It’s a stay-up-late-to-finish kind of book, and it doesn't disappoint." —Publishers Weekly
The real value here isn't just the "whodunnit" aspect. It’s the way the book forces the reader to think about empathy—even for the villains. The Naturals have to "become" the killer to catch them, which leads to some great conversations about where the line is between understanding someone and becoming like them. If they finish this and start asking for more, the series recently had a resurgence with a deluxe limited edition mystery that proves these characters still have plenty of mileage.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
