Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Look, I'll be straight with you: this is a niche movie for a niche audience. The 28-point chasm between audience and critic scores tells the whole story—this isn't about filmmaking quality, it's about ideology.

The premise (American Christian speaker kidnapped by militants in Cairo) is designed to appeal to a specific worldview, and the execution apparently doesn't transcend that narrow lane. A 5.6 IMDb and 2.4/5 Letterboxd from actual film enthusiasts versus 86% from a self-selecting audience? That's not a movie, that's a Rorschach test.

If you're looking for genuinely enriching content about Middle Eastern geopolitics, religious persecution, or cross-cultural understanding, there are far better documentaries and dramas. If you're looking for quality action thrills, there are hundreds of better options. This one's only on your radar if you're specifically hunting for faith-based action content and don't mind formulaic execution.

Free on Tubi and Roku tells you everything about its theatrical run. Skip it unless you're the exact target demographic—and even then, lower your expectations.

Age Fit

This is really for adults only (17+), and even then, mainly for viewers specifically seeking faith-based action content with a particular geopolitical perspective. The mature violence, kidnapping themes, and ideological framing make it inappropriate for teens despite the 15+ rating.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

35

Action thriller centered on kidnapping and militant uprisings lacks emotionally healthy modeling; focuses on violence and conflict in Middle Eastern setting with limited nuance. The premise involves religious/political tensions that could promote divisive worldviews rather than cooperation or understanding.

Imaginative

25

Straightforward rescue thriller with conventional genre beats. No evidence of creative storytelling or fresh perspective. Mixed critical reception (58% RT critics, 2.4/5 Letterboxd) suggests formulaic execution. Doesn't invite curiosity or creative thinking—just standard action movie mechanics.

Safe

30

Common Sense Media rates it 15+, indicating mature content. Action thriller about kidnapping and militant violence inherently contains intense scenes, likely including threat, peril, and potentially graphic violence. The geopolitical/religious tensions at its core could be triggering or confusing without context. Not something a young child should stumble into.

Enriching

20

Limited enrichment value. While it touches on geopolitical issues, the 5.6 IMDb and low Letterboxd score suggest shallow treatment. High audience score (86% RT) vs. low critical scores indicates it may play to confirmation bias rather than offering genuine insight into complex Middle Eastern politics. More likely to reinforce stereotypes than build empathy or understanding.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

If you're specifically looking for faith-based action content, this delivers that niche (Jim Caviezel is basically typecast at this point)
The 86% audience score means someone is connecting with it—just not critics or cinephiles
Could spark conversations about religious persecution and geopolitical complexity, if you're willing to provide a lot of context and counterbalance

⚠

What to Watch For

Kidnapping, violence, and militant uprising content—definitely 15+ territory
The huge gap between critic scores (58%, 5.6 IMDb) and audience scores (86%) is a red flag for ideologically-driven rather than quality-driven appeal
Likely presents Middle Eastern conflicts through a very particular lens that may reinforce rather than challenge stereotypes
This is streaming on free platforms (Tubi, Roku), which tells you something about its theatrical performance and overall quality

Conversation Starters

"What do you think motivates people to take such extreme actions in conflicts like this?"
"How do movies about real-world conflicts shape what we think about those places and people?"
"Do you think this movie showed the 'other side' fairly, or was it pretty one-sided?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Infidel? Put this WISE score on your site