Hershel and the Hanukkah Goblins – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Hershel and the Hanukkah Goblins

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2014

82%

WISE Score

4.9

Amazon

A clever trickster outsmarts genuinely creepy goblins to save Hanukkah—brains over brawn in this Caldecott Honor folk tale.

Hershel and the Hanukkah Goblins

book

2014

82%

WISE Score

4.9

Amazon

A clever trickster outsmarts genuinely creepy goblins to save Hanukkah—brains over brawn in this Caldecott Honor folk tale.

4.9

Jump to

Also rated on

4.9

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is the real deal—a Caldecott Honor book that's earned its place as a Hanukkah classic. Hershel uses his brain to outwit scary goblins night after night, and kids genuinely find it exciting and a little frightening (in a good way).

The illustrations don't pull punches. These goblins are creepy, with leering faces and menacing presence. If your kid still gets nightmares from mildly spooky content, wait a year or two. But for kids who like a little thrill with their picture books, this delivers.

What makes it great is that Hershel wins through cleverness, not strength. Each night he faces a new goblin and has to think his way out. It's suspenseful, it's funny, and it introduces Jewish folklore in a way that feels alive rather than educational. The 25-year track record speaks for itself—families keep coming back to this one.

Age Fit

Best for ages 5-10. The deliberately scary goblins make this too intense for very young or sensitive kids, but school-age children who can handle a little spookiness will love the suspense and clever trickster hero. Older elementary kids still enjoy the story's wit and cultural richness.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Features a clever protagonist who uses wit and courage (not violence) to help a community in need. Models bravery, problem-solving, and standing up for what's right. The trickster hero tradition is emotionally healthy, though the goblins are intentionally scary (part of the folk tale tradition). Positive themes of perseverance and community celebration.

Imaginative

Original tale drawing on Jewish folklore with creative goblin designs described as 'equal parts terrifying and ridiculous.' The night-by-night structure builds suspense while Hershel outsmarts each goblin differently. Caldecott Honor recognition confirms strong visual storytelling. The blend of traditional folk hero with fantastical creatures invites curiosity about both Jewish culture and folklore traditions.

Safe

The goblins are deliberately frightening—Trina Schart Hyman's illustrations are described as 'leering' and the creatures are meant to be scary. This is age-appropriate spookiness for a picture book (similar to Where the Wild Things Are), but sensitive kids might find it genuinely unsettling. No violence, gore, or inappropriate content, but the fear factor is real and intentional. One review notes concern about 'anti-Semitic goblins' but context suggests this is a misreading—the goblins are antagonists trying to stop Hanukkah, not Jewish stereotypes.

Enriching

Introduces children to Jewish culture, Hanukkah traditions, and the folk hero Hershel of Ostropol. Winner of Sydney Taylor Honor (recognizing authentic Jewish content). Teaches problem-solving through wit rather than force. The 25th anniversary edition includes an afterword explaining the book's origins, adding educational context. Strong cultural literacy value for both Jewish and non-Jewish families. Multiple prestigious awards (Caldecott Honor, ALA Notable) confirm literary merit.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Caldecott Honor book that's been a family favorite for 25+ years with a 4.9 Amazon rating
Teaches kids that wit and cleverness can triumph over scary situations—Hershel never resorts to violence
Authentic Jewish cultural content (Sydney Taylor Honor) that introduces Hanukkah traditions through an engaging story
The night-by-night structure builds suspense while showing perseverance—Hershel faces down goblins one after another
Trina Schart Hyman's illustrations are legitimately memorable—goblins that are both ridiculous and terrifying

⚠

What to Watch For

The goblins are meant to be scary, and they are—this isn't sanitized spookiness, so skip it if your kid is very sensitive to creepy imagery
It's a picture book but the story has real tension and suspense across eight nights, so younger kids might need reassurance
Some kids might ask questions about why goblins would hate Hanukkah—good opportunity to talk about how stories use villains

Conversation Starters

"Which goblin do you think was the scariest? Which one was the silliest?"
"How did Hershel trick each goblin? Could you come up with a different way to outsmart them?"
"Why do you think the goblins wanted to stop the village from celebrating Hanukkah?"
"If you were Hershel, would you have been brave enough to stay in the synagogue alone with the goblins?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic