This is a solid, well-crafted middle grade novel that earned its Newbery for good reason. Four kids who wouldn't normally connect end up saving the day together, and Kelly gives each one a distinct voice and real struggles—family pressure, loneliness, the desire to be seen.

The Filipino cultural elements feel organic, not like a diversity checklist. Valencia's deafness is handled with respect and specificity. The bully gets depth without excusing his behavior. It's the kind of book that makes kids who feel different see themselves as potential heroes.

That said, it's not revolutionary. The 'misfit kids band together' formula is well-worn, and some reviews note it doesn't quite reach the heights of Kelly's other work. The folktales might scare younger or anxious readers. But for most 8-13 year olds, this is an engaging, empathy-building read that moves quickly and sticks the landing.