Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is one of those rare books that actually deserves its classic status. Lobel captures friendship with more emotional honesty than most contemporary kids' books manage, and he does it in simple language that beginning readers can handle.

The stories are genuinely moving—'The Letter' will get you every time—and Toad's anxious, dramatic personality is weirdly relatable even for adults. But let's be real: this is a 1970 book, and it feels like it. The illustrations are lovely but distinctly retro, the pacing is slow, and nothing explodes or transforms or goes on an epic quest.

For kids who already love reading, or who respond to gentle, character-driven stories, this is gold. For kids who need more action or visual stimulation, it might be a tough sell. It's the kind of book that works best when you're not forcing it—read it aloud at bedtime, let them discover it on their own, or use the Apple TV+ adaptation as a gateway drug.

Bottom line: It's earned its place in the canon, but don't be surprised if your iPad-native kid needs some convincing.

Age Fit

Best for ages 4-8, either as a read-aloud for preschoolers or independent reading for early elementary kids. The emotional themes resonate across this range, though older elementary kids may find it too babyish unless they're already fans.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

98

Five gentle stories about two friends who consistently show up for each other with patience, kindness, and genuine care. Frog waits for Toad to wake up from hibernation, helps him find his lost button, and encourages him when he's self-conscious. The emotional tone is warm without being saccharine, and the pacing is calm and contemplative—perfect for bedtime or quiet reading moments.

Imaginative

72

The stories are charming character studies rather than fantastical adventures. There's creativity in how Lobel captures small moments—writing a letter, telling a story, searching for a button—and makes them feel meaningful. The illustrations are distinctive and expressive. But it's not asking kids to build worlds or explore big ideas; it's more observational and reflective than inventive.

Safe

100

Completely safe for any age. No violence, no scary moments, no surprise content. The most dramatic thing that happens is Toad getting embarrassed about his bathing suit. Common Sense Media parent reviews confirm it's appropriate for early readers with no concerns whatsoever.

Enriching

88

These stories teach emotional intelligence in subtle, sophisticated ways. Kids see what real friendship looks like—not just fun times, but patience when someone's grumpy, persistence in making someone feel better, and the vulnerability of admitting you're scared or embarrassed. The 'The Letter' story is particularly moving about loneliness and thoughtfulness. As an I Can Read Level 2 book, it also builds reading confidence with engaging text that rewards effort.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Models what real friendship actually looks like—showing up, being patient, making someone feel less alone
Perfect bridge between picture books and chapter books for emerging readers who need a confidence boost
Quietly funny in ways that land with both kids and adults (Toad's dramatics are extremely relatable)
Caldecott Honor winner with genuinely lovely illustrations that capture emotion in simple lines
The kind of book kids remember decades later—there's something about these two that sticks with you

⚠

What to Watch For

The pacing is deliberately slow and contemplative—kids raised on Bluey or fast-cut YouTube might need adjustment time
Published in 1970, and it shows—the vibe is very much 'your grandma's bookshelf' (which can be cozy or dated depending on the kid)
Some kids find it boring because nothing dramatic happens—it's all feelings and small moments
Best as a read-aloud first, then independent reading once they're hooked on the characters

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Toad was sad about not getting any mail? Have you ever felt left out like that?"
"Frog waited a long time for Toad to wake up. When have you been patient with a friend?"
"Toad didn't want anyone to see him in his bathing suit. What do you think Frog should have done?"
"If you could write a letter to someone right now, who would it be and what would you say?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Frog and Toad Are Friends Arnold Lobel? Put this WISE score on your site