Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is solid middle-grade fiction that tackles catfishing and digital deception without being a heavy-handed after-school special. Maisie's motivation—being relentlessly bullied about her body—makes her revenge plot understandable even when it's wrong, and that moral complexity is what makes the book work.
The premise feels current and relevant (kids are absolutely creating fake profiles and catfishing each other), and the consequences feel real. When the actual Sienna shows up, things get messy in ways that teach important lessons about online behavior without feeling preachy.
It's not groundbreaking literature, but it's engaging enough to keep middle schoolers reading while delivering genuinely useful digital citizenship lessons. The 4.5-star rating suggests it lands well with its audience. Good choice for kids who need to understand why catfishing is harmful beyond just 'it's wrong because adults said so.'
Age Fit
Best for 9-13 year olds who are starting to navigate social media and understand the complexities of online identity. The bullying and body image themes require some emotional maturity, but the lessons are spot-on for this age group.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
72
Addresses bullying, body image, and online deception with emotional weight appropriate for middle-grade readers. The protagonist's revenge plot creates moral complexity that could spark good discussions, though the arc involves deception and manipulation before resolution. Models real consequences for online actions.
Imaginative
68
Tackles timely themes of catfishing, digital identity, and social media deception in a way that feels relevant to modern kids. The premise is engaging and contemporary, though it follows a fairly predictable 'consequences of deception' narrative structure without groundbreaking originality.
Safe
78
Age-appropriate exploration of cyberbullying and online deception without graphic content. The bullying themes and body-shaming elements could be triggering for kids dealing with similar issues, but the book handles them responsibly. No violence, sexual content, or truly shocking material—just realistic middle school cruelty.
Enriching
76
Strong teaching moments about digital citizenship, consequences of online deception, empathy, and the real harm of catfishing. Addresses body image, bullying, and identity in ways that build emotional intelligence. The revenge-to-redemption arc offers meaningful character growth and ethical complexity.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Tackles catfishing and digital identity in a way that feels genuinely relevant to today's kids navigating social media
Addresses body image and bullying head-on without being preachy—Maisie's pain and anger feel real
Strong lessons about online deception and its ripple effects, plus what happens when the real person behind the stolen photos shows up
The moral complexity of a protagonist doing something wrong for understandable reasons makes for good discussions
4.5-star Amazon rating suggests it resonates with readers
⚠
What to Watch For
Bullying and body-shaming content could hit hard for kids dealing with similar issues—check in about how they're feeling
The protagonist's revenge scheme means she's doing genuinely manipulative things for a good chunk of the book before facing consequences
Some kids might need help processing the ethics of catfishing and why 'they deserved it' isn't actually a justification
Conversation Starters
"Maisie felt like revenge was her only option. What else could she have done? Why do you think she went this route?"
"Have you ever seen someone pretend to be someone else online? How did that make you feel?"
"The book shows how catfishing hurts multiple people—Maisie, the kids she's targeting, and the real Sienna. Who do you think got hurt the most?"
"If you were Maisie's friend and found out what she was doing, what would you say to her?"
