Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the kind of book that should be in every home and classroom library. Joanna Ho has created something rare: a picture book that's both achingly beautiful and developmentally crucial.
For Asian and Asian-American families, this is essential reading—it names and validates an experience many kids have (noticing their eyes look different, wondering if that's okay) and transforms it into celebration. For all families, it's a masterclass in how to talk about differences without making them deficits.
The poetic language elevates this beyond typical self-esteem books. 'Eyes that kiss in the corners' and 'glow like warm tea' aren't just pretty phrases—they're teaching kids to see beauty in unexpected ways and think metaphorically about identity.
The only caveat: this isn't a quick bedtime read. The lyrical text deserves slow reading and discussion. But that's a feature, not a bug. This is a book you'll return to over and over as your kid grows and understands new layers.
Age Fit
Best for ages 4-8, the sweet spot for identity formation and understanding differences. Younger kids (3-4) can appreciate the illustrations and rhythm, while older elementary kids (7-8) can grasp the deeper themes about beauty standards and cultural pride.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
98
A deeply affirming story about self-acceptance, family connection, and cultural identity. Models emotional health through the protagonist's journey from comparison to celebration. The intergenerational bond between daughter, mother, grandmother, and sister creates a warm, loving framework. No negative behaviors, conflict, or chaos—just gentle, powerful affirmation.
Imaginative
88
Lyrical, poetic language transforms a simple physical feature into metaphor: eyes that 'kiss in the corners,' 'glow like warm tea,' and 'crinkle into crescent moons.' The imagery invites children to see beauty in unexpected places and think creatively about identity. While not interactive or world-building in the traditional sense, it sparks imaginative thinking about heritage and self-perception.
Safe
100
Zero safety concerns. A gentle picture book with no violence, scary content, or mature themes. Purely focused on self-love and family. Multiple starred reviews and widespread library/educator adoption confirm its appropriateness. Common Sense Media and parent reviews show universal praise with no red flags.
Enriching
96
Exceptional social-emotional learning vehicle. Directly addresses identity formation, cultural pride, and self-acceptance—critical developmental work for young children, especially Asian and Asian-American kids who may feel 'different.' Teaches empathy and celebrates diversity. Multiple awards (Bank Street Best Children's Book, School Library Journal Best Book, Golden Poppy Award) validate its educational impact. Provides meaningful conversation starters about heritage, beauty standards, and family.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Addresses a real pain point many Asian kids face: feeling different because of their physical features, and transforms it into pride
Gorgeous, poetic language that elevates the picture book format—'eyes that kiss in the corners' is just stunning
Intergenerational connection through mother, grandmother, and sister creates a powerful lineage of strength and beauty
Multiple starred reviews from Kirkus, School Library Journal, and Booklist—this isn't just feel-good fluff, it's genuinely excellent literature
Perfect entry point for talking about beauty standards, cultural identity, and what makes each of us special
⚠
What to Watch For
The poetic language is beautiful but may be abstract for very young kids—this works best as a read-aloud with discussion
Most powerful for Asian/Asian-American children who may relate directly, but valuable for all kids learning about diversity
Some kids might need help connecting the metaphors (eyes like warm tea, crescent moons) to the deeper meaning
Conversation Starters
"What do you think makes your eyes special? What about other parts of you?"
"Have you ever felt different from your friends? How did that feel?"
"The girl in the story finds beauty in being like her mom and grandma—what traits do you share with our family?"
"Why do you think the author chose to compare eyes to warm tea and crescent moons?"
"What would you want to celebrate about yourself in a book?"
