Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Eloise in Paris is a charming classic with gorgeous, detail-packed illustrations and a distinctive voice. If you're a parent who loves vintage children's books or wants to introduce your kid to mid-century Paris, this delivers.
But let's be real: this book is nearly 70 years old, and it shows. The references are obscure (who's Richard Avedon to a 6-year-old in 2025?), the pacing is leisurely, and Eloise herself is... a lot. She's the original chaos child—precocious, bratty, and utterly unmanageable. Some kids will find her hilarious and liberating; others will be bored.
The 4.8 Amazon rating suggests plenty of nostalgic parents love it, but that doesn't mean your kid will sit through it without wandering off to watch Bluey. If your child already loves the original Eloise or has a thing for vintage aesthetics, go for it. Otherwise, there are more engaging modern picture books about travel and curiosity that won't require a history lesson to appreciate.
Age Fit
Best for 4-8 year olds who enjoy vintage picture books or have a connection to Paris. Younger kids can appreciate the illustrations during read-alouds, but the 1950s references and dated style may not land with modern elementary schoolers who expect faster-paced, contemporary stories.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
78
Eloise's enthusiastic, curious spirit and adventure through Paris models exploration and joy. The tone is playful and age-appropriate for young readers. However, Eloise is famously mischievous and somewhat bratty—she's a precocious Plaza Hotel kid who does whatever she wants. This isn't necessarily bad, but parents should know she's not exactly a model of obedience or cooperation.
Imaginative
85
The book transports kids to 1950s Paris with whimsical illustrations dotted with real celebrities (Dior, Yves Saint Laurent, Lena Horne). Hilary Knight's artwork is distinctive and charming, inviting kids to explore every corner of the pages. Eloise's perspective—doing 'everything' in Paris—encourages imaginative travel and curiosity about the world.
Safe
95
This is a classic children's picture book with no concerning content. No violence, scary scenes, or inappropriate themes. The only minor note is that Eloise is a bit spoiled and impulsive, but that's a character trait, not a safety issue. Books are generally very safe, and this is no exception.
Enriching
72
Introduces young readers to Paris landmarks, French culture, and mid-century glamour. The celebrity cameos and historical setting offer conversation opportunities. However, the book is more about whimsy and entertainment than deep learning—it's fun and charming but not particularly educational beyond basic cultural exposure. The 1950s setting may feel dated to modern kids.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Hilary Knight's distinctive illustrations are packed with delightful details and real mid-century celebrities
Introduces young readers to Paris landmarks and French culture through a child's enthusiastic lens
Eloise's boundless curiosity and confidence can be inspiring—she's fearless and does everything
The quirky, stream-of-consciousness narration style is unique and fun to read aloud
Part of a beloved classic series that has enchanted generations
⚠
What to Watch For
Eloise is decidedly NOT a role model for good behavior—she's impulsive, spoiled, and does whatever she wants
The 1950s setting and references (Christian Dior, Richard Avedon) will fly over most modern kids' heads
The illustrations and pacing feel very dated; some kids may find it boring compared to contemporary picture books
Best appreciated by kids who already love vintage aesthetics or have been to Paris
Conversation Starters
"If you could visit any city in the world like Eloise, where would you go and what would you do?"
"Eloise does a lot of things without asking permission. When do you think it's okay to be adventurous, and when should you check with a grown-up first?"
"What do you notice in the illustrations? Can you spot any famous people or interesting details?"
"How is Paris in this book different from how cities look today?"
