Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Play

Xbox

PlayStation

PC/Steam

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the uncomfortable truth: eFootball launched as one of the most disastrous game releases in history. Konami took the beloved Pro Evolution Soccer series, rebranded it, made it free-to-play, and released a buggy, feature-stripped mess that enraged fans worldwide.

Years later, it's improved but still struggles with identity. The core soccer gameplay can be decent, but it's buried under loot box mechanics for player acquisition, limited free content, and unmoderated online play where kids will absolutely encounter inappropriate language.

For soccer-loving kids, this is a hard sell. EA Sports FC (the new FIFA) offers better gameplay, more content, and a more polished experience. eFootball's main advantage is being free, but the monetization pressure and quality issues make that "free" tag feel expensive in other ways.

If your kid is already playing and enjoying it? Fine. But if you're choosing a soccer game for the first time, spend the money on EA Sports FC instead. You'll get better value and fewer headaches.

Age Fit

Best for soccer-obsessed kids 10+ who can handle online competition and resist spending pressure. Younger kids (8-9) can play offline modes with supervision, but the monetization model and online toxicity make this tricky. Teens will likely prefer EA Sports FC unless they're deeply invested in eFootball's specific player roster.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

78

Soccer simulation with clean sports gameplay and team-based cooperation. ESRB rates it E for Everyone with only mild language concerns. No toxic content in core gameplay, though unmoderated multiplayer could expose kids to inappropriate language from other players.

Imaginative

42

Standard soccer sim with limited creative expression. Players follow real-world football rules and tactics with some team customization, but it's fundamentally a recreation of existing sport rather than imaginative play. The free-to-play model constrains content availability, limiting experimentation.

Safe

58

ESRB rated E with mild language and in-game purchases including random items (loot box mechanics). Users interact online without clear moderation. The 2021 launch was notoriously buggy and poorly received, creating frustration. Free-to-play model with gacha-style player acquisition pushes monetization, though not as aggressively as some competitors.

Enriching

48

Teaches soccer strategy, team tactics, and sportsmanship basics. However, the disastrous 2021 launch and ongoing quality issues mean players spend more time frustrated than learning. Limited free content reduces skill-building opportunities. IGDB rating of 69/100 reflects mediocre reception. Not engaging enough to deliver meaningful sports education.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Free to download and play basic matches without spending money
Features real teams and players for kids who follow professional soccer
Teaches soccer tactics, formations, and strategic thinking
Rated E for Everyone—appropriate sports content without violence
Cross-platform play lets kids compete with friends on different consoles

⚠

What to Watch For

Loot box mechanics for player packs create gambling-adjacent pressure to spend real money
Unmoderated online multiplayer means kids will encounter trash talk and inappropriate language
The 2021 launch was catastrophically bad—missing features, terrible bugs, widely panned as one of the worst game releases ever
Limited free content pushes players toward spending to remain competitive
Honestly? EA Sports FC (formerly FIFA) is just a better soccer game for kids

Conversation Starters

"What soccer teams or players do you like to use? Do you follow any of them in real life?"
"Have you run into anyone being mean or using bad language online? How did you handle it?"
"Does the game make you feel like you need to buy player packs to win? How does that feel?"
"What soccer strategies have you learned? Can you explain an offside trap or a counter-attack?"
"Would you rather play this or go kick a ball around outside?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic