Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is exactly what a good elementary-age graphic novel should be: fun, fast-paced, visually engaging, and sneakily thoughtful about real kid issues like fitting in and stereotyping. The premise is genuinely clever—making humans the feared aliens is a smart twist that helps kids see prejudice from a new angle without feeling like a lecture.

The NYT review nailed it: good art, good design, tight story. It's not going to change anyone's life, but it's a solid pick for the 7-10 crowd, especially reluctant readers who need something visual and funny to keep them turning pages. The 2012 publication date means it's not quite as polished or meme-savvy as today's graphic novels, but it holds up fine.

If your kid loved Dog Man or Captain Underpants and is ready for something with slightly more story substance (but still plenty of silly), this is a great bridge. It's completely safe, genuinely imaginative, and tackles friendship and belonging without being preachy. Not a forever classic, but a really solid library checkout or rainy afternoon read.

Age Fit

Best for ages 7-11, especially kids who love graphic novels, space stories, or are dealing with new-school anxiety themselves. The cartoony style and accessible format work great for reluctant readers, but middle schoolers will likely find it too young.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

82

Lighthearted graphic novel with cartoony illustrations that tackles friendship, being the new kid, and stereotyping without being preachy. The humor is silly and age-appropriate, the tone is consistently upbeat, and it models cooperation between Bud and his alien friend Gort. No mean-spirited content, just light suspense and kid-friendly adventure.

Imaginative

88

Excellent premise that flips the 'new kid at school' anxiety into an intergalactic adventure where humans are the feared aliens. Creative worldbuilding with Cosmos Academy, anti-gravity Zero-Ball, and diverse alien characters that are visually distinct. The concept of going undercover as an exchange student while Earth's location is hidden is genuinely inventive. NYT praised the 'good art, good design, tight story.'

Safe

95

Graphic novel format with cartoony illustrations and 'lightly suspenseful plot' per Common Sense Media. No violence, gore, scary content, or inappropriate themes. The threat of being 'expelled into outer space' is played for humor rather than genuine terror. As a book, there are no privacy concerns, ads, or social features. Completely safe for independent young readers.

Enriching

75

Makes solid points about friendship, being judged on stereotypes, and navigating new social situations—all relevant to elementary-age kids. The fish-out-of-water story offers perspective on prejudice and fear of the unknown. Graphic novel format supports visual literacy and is accessible for reluctant readers. However, it's primarily entertainment-focused rather than deeply educational, and the 'L. Frank Baum flourish' ending suggests a fairly straightforward resolution.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Flips the 'new kid' anxiety on its head by making humans the feared species in the galaxy—clever premise that helps kids see stereotyping from a fresh angle
Graphic novel format with distinct alien characters and cartoony art makes it perfect for reluctant readers or kids transitioning to chapter books
Silly humor (anti-gravity Zero-Ball! Paranoid Principal Lepton!) keeps it light while still addressing real friendship and belonging themes
Short, tight story with good pacing—NYT called it 'remarkably complete' with no filler
Zero scary content, just fun space adventure with a Wizard of Oz-style ending

⚠

What to Watch For

It's from 2012, so some of the visual style and humor might feel slightly dated compared to current graphic novels like Dogman or Amulet
The sports subplot (Zero-Ball) might not land for kids who aren't into athletic stories
At 4.1 stars on Amazon, it's solid but not universally beloved—some kids will devour it, others might find it just okay

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think everyone at Cosmos Academy was scared of Earthlings? Have you ever been scared of someone before you got to know them?"
"Bud had to pretend to be good at Zero-Ball even though he wasn't. Have you ever felt pressure to be good at something you're not?"
"If you went to school in space, what would be the hardest part? What would be the coolest part?"
"The book talks about stereotypes—what does that mean, and can you think of examples from real life?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Earthling! Mark Fearing