Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Dear Evan Hansen is not an easy read, and it's not supposed to be. It's a gut-punch exploration of what happens when a lonely, anxious kid makes a terrible choice and then keeps making it worse. The mental health representation is solid—Evan's anxiety is portrayed with painful accuracy, not as a quirk or a plot device.

But here's the thing: you're going to spend a lot of this book watching Evan do awful things to grieving people, and it's uncomfortable. That's the point, but it also means this isn't for everyone. Some teens will find it cathartic and insightful. Others will find it triggering or just too heavy.

The book earned its popularity because it speaks to real issues—the loneliness epidemic, the performance of social media empathy, the way mental illness can make you feel invisible. But it requires a reader who can sit with moral complexity and not need their protagonist to be likable.

If your teen is dealing with suicidal thoughts or fresh grief, maybe not now. If they're emotionally ready for a challenging, conversation-starting read about authenticity and consequence, this delivers.

Age Fit

This is for older teens (15+) who have the emotional maturity to handle suicide, mental illness, and morally gray protagonists. The content is too heavy and triggering for middle schoolers, and even high schoolers should go in prepared for what they're getting.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

45

The book centers on a protagonist who builds an elaborate lie about being best friends with a classmate who died by suicide, deceiving a grieving family for personal gain and social status. While Evan eventually faces consequences and the story explores guilt and authenticity, the extended deception and manipulation of vulnerable people creates a morally complex narrative that doesn't model healthy behavior. The anxiety representation is authentic, but the choices Evan makes are deeply problematic.

Imaginative

62

The dual-perspective structure (Evan's present-day narrative alternating with Connor's backstory) offers an interesting narrative approach. The exploration of social media virality, performative activism, and the construction of identity in the digital age shows creative engagement with contemporary themes. However, it's an adaptation of the musical rather than wholly original, and the story follows fairly conventional YA coming-of-age beats.

Safe

35

Common Sense Media confirms this deals with suicide, grief, anxiety, depression, and loneliness as central themes. The book includes a teen suicide (Connor Murphy), detailed exploration of mental health struggles, and the emotional manipulation of a grieving family. While these topics are handled thoughtfully rather than gratuitously, this is heavy, triggering content that requires significant emotional maturity. Not something a younger teen should stumble into unprepared.

Enriching

72

The book offers genuine insight into anxiety disorders, the performative nature of social media compassion, and the complexity of grief. It tackles authenticity, belonging, and the consequences of our choices with nuance. The mental health representation (both Evan's anxiety and Connor's struggles) is well-researched and empathy-building. Readers will come away with deeper understanding of how social media can distort human connection and how desperation for belonging can lead to terrible choices.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Authentic, detailed portrayal of anxiety disorder that many teens will recognize and feel seen by
Dual perspective structure gives voice to Connor Murphy's backstory, humanizing the 'troubled kid' beyond the tragedy
Sharp commentary on performative social media activism and how online compassion can be hollow
Doesn't let Evan off the hook—the book grapples with the real harm his lies cause and the complexity of seeking redemption
Opens conversations about mental health, belonging, and what we owe to each other in an age of digital connection

⚠

What to Watch For

Teen suicide is a central plot point—this isn't background content, it's the inciting incident
The protagonist does genuinely awful things (manipulating a grieving family for months) that may be hard to read
Heavy themes throughout: depression, anxiety attacks, loneliness, family dysfunction, and the aftermath of suicide
Not a feel-good story—it's emotionally draining and morally complicated
Requires emotional maturity to process the ethical questions without clear answers

Conversation Starters

"Do you think Evan's anxiety excuses any of his choices? Where's the line between understanding someone's struggles and holding them accountable?"
"Have you ever seen people online jump on a cause or tragedy in a way that felt more about them than actually helping?"
"Connor's chapters show he was struggling long before he died. What do you think could have made a difference for him?"
"If you were Zoe or the Murphys and found out the truth, could you forgive Evan? What would that even look like?"
"The book shows how desperate Evan was to be seen and to matter. What are healthier ways people can find that sense of belonging?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Dear Evan Hansen: The Novel Val Emmich, Steven Levenson, Benj Pasek, Justin Paul