Crenshaw is one of those books that's more important than entertaining. Applegate handles child poverty with grace and without melodrama, using the magical realism of an imaginary cat to soften the blow. It's a genuine empathy-builder that can open conversations about economic inequality.

But let's be honest: multiple reviewers call it slow, plotless, and even boring. There's no dramatic arc, no real climax—just a kid processing fear and uncertainty with the help of a talking cat. For some readers, that quiet contemplation is exactly what they need. For others, it'll feel like nothing happens.

The WISE score reflects its emotional intelligence and safety, but accounts for the engagement problem. If your kid needs page-turning action, skip it. If they're ready for a gentle, honest look at what some families face, this delivers.