Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is a powerhouse YA fantasy debut that deserves its hype—Adeyemi's worldbuilding is gorgeous, the cultural representation is important, and the story tackles big questions about power and justice. But let's be clear: this is not a gentle read.
The violence is real and sometimes graphic. The emotional weight is heavy. A mother is murdered, genocide is central to the plot, and the protagonist grapples with trauma throughout. Multiple parent reviewers compare it to an R-rated movie, and that tracks.
If your teen is 14+ and ready for intense content, this is a rich, engaging read that will stick with them. The audiobook narration is spectacular. But if they're sensitive to violence or prefer lighter fare, wait a year or two. This is fantasy with teeth.
Age Fit
Best for mature teens 14-15+ who can handle graphic violence and heavy themes of genocide and trauma. The cultural richness and complex storytelling will appeal to older teens and adults who love fantasy.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
62
The book models courage, resistance against oppression, and found family bonds. However, it includes significant violence (some descriptive), intense themes of genocide and trauma (Zélie's mother was killed), and passionate romantic tension. The emotional weight is heavy—this isn't a light read. It handles serious themes with maturity but the tone can be dark and intense throughout.
Imaginative
88
Adeyemi creates a richly detailed West African-inspired fantasy world with an original magic system (Burners, Tiders, Reapers), mythical creatures (snow leoponaires), and vengeful spirits. The worldbuilding is immersive and fresh in the YA fantasy landscape, drawing from Yoruba culture and mythology rather than the typical Eurocentric fantasy tropes. It invites readers into a wholly realized alternate world.
Safe
58
Multiple reviews flag descriptive violence throughout, including scenes of genocide, death, and combat. There's strong language and passionate kissing scenes. The opening premise involves the murder of Zélie's mother and systematic oppression. This isn't gratuitous, but it's intense and could be triggering for younger or sensitive readers. Reviews consistently recommend 14-15+ due to violence and mature themes.
Enriching
85
The novel tackles systemic oppression, genocide, resistance, and the cost of revolution with nuance. It explores themes of power, prejudice, and identity while centering Black characters in a fantasy epic—representation that matters. Readers engage with complex moral questions about violence, justice, and revenge. The West African cultural influences offer educational value. It's both entertaining and thought-provoking.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Gorgeous worldbuilding rooted in Yoruba culture and mythology—a refreshing departure from Eurocentric fantasy
Centers Black characters in an epic fantasy narrative with complex moral questions about justice and revenge
Tackles systemic oppression, genocide, and resistance with nuance and emotional depth
Bahni Turpin's audiobook narration is award-winning and brings the story to vivid life
Fast-paced adventure with romance, magic, and high stakes that keeps readers hooked
⚠
What to Watch For
Significant violence including descriptive combat, death scenes, and the aftermath of genocide—not for sensitive readers
Heavy emotional content: the protagonist's mother was murdered, and trauma permeates the story
Some strong language and passionate kissing scenes (not explicit but present)
Dark tone throughout—this is about oppression and revolution, not a lighthearted fantasy romp
Conversation Starters
"Zélie has to decide whether to trust people who were her enemies. When have you had to work with someone you didn't like or trust?"
"The book shows how a king used fear to control people by taking away their magic. What are examples from history where governments tried to control people by taking away their power?"
"Zélie struggles with whether violence is justified to fight back against oppression. What do you think about that? Are there limits?"
"The magic system is tied to West African culture and mythology. What did you learn about Yoruba traditions? How is this different from other fantasy books you've read?"