Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Blubber is important, not fun. It's the literary equivalent of eating your vegetables—good for you, but nobody's asking for seconds.

Judy Blume deserves credit for tackling bullying from the bully's perspective decades before it became a common trope. The book forces kids to sit with discomfort, to watch an ordinary girl participate in cruelty, and to reckon with how easily any of us can become complicit. When Jill gets a taste of her own medicine, the lesson lands hard.

But let's be real: this is a 1970s book with a 2014 reissue, and it shows. The setting feels distant, the social dynamics are pre-digital, and the prose is straightforward to the point of flatness. Modern kids raised on fast-paced, high-stakes middle-grade fiction may find this slow and depressing. It's not a page-turner—it's homework that happens to be in novel form.

That said, if you're looking for a book to anchor a conversation about bullying, peer pressure, or standing up, Blubber delivers. Just know you're signing up for a discussion, not a delight.

Age Fit

Best for ages 9-13 who are navigating or ready to discuss complex peer dynamics. The emotional weight and dated setting make it a tougher sell for younger or more sensitive readers, but it's a valuable tool for kids mature enough to handle uncomfortable truths about social cruelty.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

58

The book presents bullying from the bully's perspective, which is valuable but uncomfortable. Jill isn't a kind character—she actively participates in tormenting Linda. The eventual turn where Jill becomes a target herself provides a moral lesson, but the journey is emotionally rough and doesn't model positive behavior until the consequences hit. It's realistic rather than warm, and the tone reflects the cruelty of fifth-grade social dynamics without sugarcoating.

Imaginative

42

This is straightforward realistic fiction focused on social dynamics and bullying. There's no world-building, fantasy elements, or creative problem-solving. The narrative is grounded in everyday school life circa 1970s (originally published 1974, reissued 2014). It doesn't invite creative play or exploration—it's a mirror held up to uncomfortable social realities. Judy Blume's candid writing style is notable, but the story itself doesn't spark imagination.

Safe

72

Books are generally safe, and Blubber has no graphic violence, sexual content, or truly shocking material. However, Common Sense Media notes it's a 'brutally honest look at bullying,' and the emotional content—relentless teasing, name-calling, social cruelty—can be distressing for sensitive readers. A child reading this might feel anxious or upset by the meanness. It's age-appropriate for upper elementary/middle grade but not a light read.

Enriching

76

This is where Blubber shines. It's a classic for a reason: it tackles bullying from the perpetrator's perspective, forcing readers to confront complicity and mob mentality. Jill's arc—from bystander/participant to victim—builds empathy and self-awareness. The book sparks crucial conversations about standing up, peer pressure, and the consequences of cruelty. Judy Blume's honest approach to tough topics has made this required reading in many schools for decades.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Rare perspective: shows how ordinary kids become bullies through peer pressure and mob mentality
Sparks essential conversations about standing up, complicity, and empathy
Judy Blume's trademark honesty—she doesn't lecture, just shows kids as they really are
The turn where Jill becomes the target is a powerful lesson in consequences and perspective-taking
A middle-grade classic that's been starting tough discussions for 50 years

⚠

What to Watch For

This is emotionally heavy—relentless teasing and name-calling throughout most of the book
Your kid will spend most of the story with an unlikeable protagonist who does mean things
The 1970s setting (no cell phones, different social norms) feels dated and might distance modern readers
Sensitive kids may find the cruelty upsetting; best for those ready to discuss tough social dynamics

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Jill went along with bullying Linda, even though she didn't start it?"
"Have you ever seen someone being left out or teased at school? What did you do?"
"How did Jill's feelings change when she became the target? What do you think she learned?"
"Is there a 'Wendy' in your class—someone who leads the social pack? How does that affect everyone else?"
"If you were Jill's friend, what would you have said to her about how she was treating Linda?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic