Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the truth: Anne of Green Gables is a legitimate literary classic with a 4.8 Amazon rating and genuine cultural significance. Anne herself is wonderful—imaginative, flawed, determined, and real.

But let's be honest about 2025: this is a tough sell for most modern kids. The pacing is glacial by today's standards, with pages devoted to describing landscapes and Anne's internal musings. The vocabulary is advanced (Grade 7 reading level), and the cultural context feels very distant. Many kids who start it never finish.

This works beautifully for a specific type of reader—the patient, book-loving kid who enjoys character development over action, or the advanced 10-year-old who devours everything. For everyone else, consider the Netflix adaptation "Anne with an E" as a gateway, or save this for when they're older and more willing to meet a classic on its own terms.

The 8-book box set is particularly ambitious—even fans often don't make it past book three. If you want to try this, start with just the first book and see if it clicks.

Age Fit

Best for advanced readers ages 10-14 who enjoy character-driven, slower-paced stories. The Grade 7 reading level and 19th-century pacing make this challenging for younger or reluctant readers, even if they're technically capable. Adults who loved it as kids may be disappointed when their own children bounce off it.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

92

L.M. Montgomery's classic models kindness, perseverance, and emotional growth through Anne's journey from orphan to beloved community member. The narrative celebrates friendship, family bonds, and personal integrity without being saccharine. Anne's imaginative spirit and occasional missteps feel authentic rather than preachy.

Imaginative

88

Anne's vivid imagination is the heart of the series—renaming places, creating elaborate fantasies, and finding beauty in everyday life. The books invite readers into a richly detailed world of Prince Edward Island and encourage creative thinking. However, the imaginative elements are more observational than interactive for the reader.

Safe

98

This is classic children's literature with zero concerning content. No violence, mature themes, or inappropriate material. The most dramatic moments involve childhood scrapes and social embarrassments. Perfect for reading aloud or independent reading without worry.

Enriching

85

Strong character development, rich vocabulary, and themes of resilience, belonging, and personal growth. Anne's journey from insecure orphan to confident woman offers meaningful lessons about identity and perseverance. The historical setting provides cultural context, though the pacing and 19th-century social norms may feel distant to modern readers.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Anne is a genuinely memorable character whose creativity and determination inspire readers across generations
Rich, descriptive language builds vocabulary and exposes kids to more complex sentence structures
Wholesome themes of belonging, friendship, and personal growth without being preachy
Zero content concerns—you can hand this to any kid without worry
For the right reader, this becomes a beloved favorite they'll remember forever

⚠

What to Watch For

The pacing is 19th-century slow—lots of description, internal monologue, and daily life details that modern kids often find boring
Grade 7 reading level with sophisticated vocabulary means many kids will struggle or lose interest
This is an 8-book box set, which is ambitious for most readers who aren't already hooked
The cultural context (orphan trains, strict gender roles, turn-of-century social norms) may feel very distant

Conversation Starters

"Anne renames everything to make it more beautiful—what would you rename in our town if you could?"
"Anne makes some pretty big mistakes (like the hair dye incident). What would you have done differently?"
"How is Anne's life as an orphan different from kids' lives today? What surprised you most about how she lived?"
"Anne has to work really hard to fit in at first. Have you ever felt like the new kid or outsider?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic