All the Answers Kate Messner – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

All the Answers Kate Messner

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2016

78%

WISE Score

4.5

Amazon

A magical pencil that answers any question sounds great—until middle schooler Ava learns some truths she wasn't ready to hear.

All the Answers Kate Messner

book

2016

78%

WISE Score

4.5

Amazon

A magical pencil that answers any question sounds great—until middle schooler Ava learns some truths she wasn't ready to hear.

4.5

Jump to

Also rated on

4.5

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is a perfectly pleasant middle-grade novel that does what it sets out to do: take a fun magical premise and use it to explore honesty, self-reliance, and family complexity. It's not going to blow anyone's mind, but it's a solid choice for kids who like realistic fiction with a dash of magic.

The pencil hook is clever enough to get reluctant readers interested, and the emotional payoff is genuine without being heavy-handed. Messner knows her audience—the pacing is brisk, the friendship feels real, and the family revelations are handled with appropriate sensitivity.

That said, it's a 2016 middle-grade novel that feels like... a 2016 middle-grade novel. It's not dated in a bad way, but it's not particularly fresh or memorable either. Your kid will probably enjoy it, finish it, and move on to the next book without looking back. Which is fine! Not every book needs to be a life-changing masterpiece. This is a good library checkout or rainy-day read.

Age Fit

Perfect for ages 8-12, right in that sweet spot where kids are navigating school pressure, friendship drama, and starting to understand that adults aren't perfect. Younger readers might need the family-secret subplot explained, while middle schoolers will get all the nuances.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

A gentle middle-grade story about friendship, family, and learning to face uncomfortable truths. The magical pencil premise creates a low-stakes framework for exploring honesty, self-reliance, and family secrets. Ava's relationship with her best friend Sophie models healthy peer support, and the emotional arc centers on personal growth rather than external conflict. The tone is warm and age-appropriate, though the family revelations add some emotional weight.

Imaginative

The magical pencil that answers questions is a clever, accessible hook that invites kids to think about what they'd ask if they could know anything. The premise explores the tension between wanting easy answers and needing to figure things out yourself. However, it's a fairly straightforward middle-grade formula—magical object leads to self-discovery—without wildly inventive world-building or truly surprising narrative turns. Solid but not groundbreaking.

Safe

Very safe for middle-grade readers. The 'family secrets' referenced in the synopsis likely involve age-appropriate revelations (adoption, family history, etc.) rather than traumatic content. No violence, scary elements, or inappropriate material. The emotional stakes involve self-discovery and family dynamics, which are handled with care in middle-grade fiction from established authors like Messner. The 4.5 Amazon rating suggests broad parent approval.

Enriching

Tackles meaningful themes about academic integrity, the difference between shortcuts and real learning, and facing difficult truths about family and identity. The pencil becomes a vehicle for exploring what happens when you rely on external answers instead of developing your own judgment. Encourages readers to think about honesty, self-reliance, and how we handle information we're not ready for. Solid character growth and emotional intelligence, though not particularly challenging or deep.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

The premise is immediately relatable: what kid hasn't wished for a cheat code to get through school and life?
Explores the difference between having answers and actually learning, which is a genuinely useful lesson without being preachy
Strong friendship dynamics between Ava and Sophie model healthy peer relationships
Family revelations add emotional depth and teach kids that sometimes uncomfortable truths are part of growing up
Kate Messner is a solid middle-grade author who knows how to balance humor, heart, and real feelings

⚠

What to Watch For

The family secrets angle might spark questions about your own family history—be ready for 'wait, is there anything you haven't told me?' conversations
Some kids might need reassurance that using help (tutoring, asking questions) is different from the magical-pencil shortcut
It's a 2016 middle-grade novel, so it reads a bit dated compared to more contemporary stories—not bad, just not super fresh

Conversation Starters

"If you had a pencil that could answer any question, what would you ask it first? What questions would you NOT want to know the answer to?"
"Ava starts relying on the pencil instead of thinking for herself. Have you ever felt like you wanted someone to just tell you the answer instead of figuring it out?"
"The book talks about family secrets. Do you think parents should tell kids everything, or are some things okay to wait until you're older to hear?"
"How do you think Ava's friendship with Sophie helped her through the story? What makes a good friend when things get complicated?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic