All Dogs Go to Heaven 2 – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

All Dogs Go to Heaven 2

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

movie1996

42%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

A forgettable direct-to-video sequel where heavenly dogs hunt for a horn—critics and audiences mostly agree it should've stayed up there.

5.5/10

33%

→

All Dogs Go to Heaven 2

movie

G, 1996

42%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

A forgettable direct-to-video sequel where heavenly dogs hunt for a horn—critics and audiences mostly agree it should've stayed up there.

5.5

33%

Jump to

Also rated on

5.5/10

33%

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

Look, this is one of those sequels that nobody asked for. The original All Dogs Go to Heaven (1989) had Don Bluth's darker, more ambitious animation style. This 1996 direct-to-video follow-up? It's a watered-down retread with cheaper animation, a recycled plot, and songs that try too hard.

The critics gave it 33%, audiences 39%, and Letterboxd users a dismal 2.8/5. That's not a conspiracy—it's just not very good. The moral lessons about family are fine, the content is safe enough for young kids, but the execution is forgettable at best.

If your 5-year-old stumbles onto this on HBO Max or Tubi, they probably won't be traumatized, but they also probably won't remember it by dinnertime. There are dozens of better animated options from the same era (Toy Story, The Iron Giant, Mulan) that actually hold up. This one's skippable unless you're really scraping the bottom of the streaming barrel.

Age Fit

Common Sense Media pegs this at 5+, which seems right for the G-rating and mild content. But honestly, even kindergarteners raised on Pixar and modern Disney might struggle to stay engaged with this dated sequel. Best for nostalgic parents or very young kids who aren't picky yet.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

The movie centers on themes of friendship, family, and helping a runaway child find his way home. Models cooperation between Charlie and Itchy as they work together on their mission. However, the devil character (in disguise) and some darker elements prevent this from being fully wholesome. The pacing is relatively balanced for a mid-90s animated sequel.

Imaginative

The premise of dogs returning from heaven to find Gabriel's Horn has some fantastical elements, but this is a direct-to-video sequel that recycles concepts from the original without adding much creative spark. The 33% critic score and 5.5/10 IMDb rating suggest uninspired execution. It's functional animated storytelling but doesn't invite much curiosity or creative thinking beyond passive viewing.

Safe

Rated G with minimal content concerns. Kids-in-Mind rates it 0.2.0 (no language, mild violence/gore). IMDb Parents Guide notes 'mild' across most categories, though mentions 'moderate frightening scenes' and some intensity around the devil character. Common Sense Media recommends age 5+. No gore, nudity, or truly shocking content, though the darker thematic elements (devil, runaway child) add some emotional weight that younger kids might find unsettling.

Enriching

Multiple sources mention lessons about 'love and the importance of family' and helping a runaway child, which provides some moral grounding. However, the poor critical reception (33% RT, 2.8/5 Letterboxd) suggests the execution is shallow. It's a basic morality tale without much depth or memorable insight. The entertainment value is equally limited—this is widely considered a forgettable sequel that doesn't offer much cognitive or emotional growth.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Positive messages about family, friendship, and helping others in need
G-rated with minimal content concerns—safe for young viewers
Some catchy songs that might stick with kids who enjoy musical numbers
The runaway child storyline could spark conversations about home and belonging

⚠

What to Watch For

The devil character (in disguise) and some darker scenes might frighten sensitive preschoolers
This is a 1996 direct-to-video sequel—the animation quality and pacing feel dated
With a 33% critic score and 5.5/10 on IMDb, even kids might find this one boring compared to modern animated fare
The runaway child theme requires some emotional maturity to process

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think David ran away from home? What would you do if a friend told you they wanted to run away?"
"Charlie and Itchy are trying to help David get back home. Why is family important even when things are hard?"
"The movie shows heaven for dogs. What do you think heaven would be like?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic