2020
WISE Score
Amazon
Think Nancy Drew but with a London Underground obsession and a secret society membership card.
4.7
4.7View →Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)
This is a winner for parents looking to swap screen time for 'page time.' It’s smart, stylish, and avoids the 'talking down' that usually makes middle-grade fiction feel like homework.
It’s the second in a series, but it stands on its own well enough. If your kid likes puzzles, secret codes, or just feeling like they're the smartest person in the room, they'll fly through this.
Perfect for the 9-12 crowd. It’s for kids who have outgrown Encyclopedia Brown but aren't quite ready for the angst and grit of YA novels.
Agatha is a sharp, determined lead who values logic and persistence. The tone is adventurous and curious rather than cynical, modeling a healthy 'can-do' attitude for preteens.
The 'Gatekeepers' Guild' secret society and the use of London’s hidden geography (like disused Tube stations) provide a great spark for kids who love world-building and mystery-solving.
It's a middle-grade novel. While it features a murder, the violence is off-page and handled with the standard 'detective story' distance suitable for 10-year-olds. No tech-related safety issues here.
Excellent for developing deductive reasoning and critical thinking. It also hooks kids into historical and cultural interest via the British Museum setting.
Agatha isn't your typical middle-grade protagonist who stumbles into a mystery because she’s bored. She’s thirteen, but she carries herself with the confidence of a seasoned detective who has seen one too many noir films. The vibe here is very much "competence porn" for the pre-teen set. While many books for this age group focus on school drama or magical destinies, Murder at the Museum treats its audience like adults.
It’s stylish. Agatha has a London Underground obsession and a membership in a secret society called the Gatekeepers' Guild. This isn't just fluff; it gives the story a layer of world-building that makes the mystery feel like it has actual stakes. If your kid finds traditional school reading lists a bit mid, this is the palate cleanser they need. It’s for the kid who wants to be the smartest person in the room and isn't afraid to prove it.
Parents often worry about jumping into a series mid-stream, but Lena Jones handles the "previously on" details without a massive info-dump. You can pick this up without having read the first book and not feel lost. That said, the lore of the Gatekeepers' Guild is a major hook. If you’re wondering why this modern-day Nancy Drew is the perfect screen-free obsession for kids who love puzzles, it’s because the series builds a world where kids are the only ones capable of seeing the truth.
The London setting is a massive plus. The British Museum isn't just a backdrop; it’s a labyrinth. For a kid sitting in a bedroom in the suburbs, the descriptions of secret passages and historical artifacts make the world feel much bigger. It’s the kind of book that might actually make a future museum trip feel like an adventure rather than a chore.
Most kid mysteries cheat. They rely on a "magic" clue found at the last minute or a villain who explains their entire plan for no reason. Jones plays fair with the reader. The clues are there if you’re paying attention. It encourages a type of active reading that is rare in "brain rot" entertainment.
If your kid is currently obsessed with Enola Holmes or the Knives Out films, this is the logical literary next step. It’s fast-paced enough to compete with a tablet, but the payoff requires a level of focus that scrolling TikTok just doesn't offer. It hits that sweet spot where the "murder" is the engine of the plot, but the logic is the star of the show. Just don't be surprised if they start looking for secret compartments in your furniture afterward.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
