Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Think Nancy Drew with a penchant for London history and secret underground tunnels. Thirteen-year-old Agatha Oddlow is back for her second case, and while the title promises a murder at the British Museum, the story keeps all violence off-page and strictly sanitized for pre-teens.
It is a fast-paced, brain-teasing mystery that respects young readers by dropping actual clues instead of relying on cheap twists. If you are looking for a page-turner to pull an eight- to twelve-year-old away from screens, this series is a prime candidate.
Age Fit
Ideal for readers ages 8 to 12 who enjoy mysteries, secret codes, and independent detective heroines.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Features an energetic, inquisitive protagonist who values friendship, observation, and doing the right thing. The tone stays cozy and adventurous without unnecessary snark or cynicism.
Imaginative
86
Packed with secret societies, hidden underground London passages, museum puzzles, and clever code-cracking that sparks curiosity.
Safe
92
Despite 'Murder' in the title, all violence is kept off-page and handled with a light, classic detective-story distance similar to Enola Holmes.
Enriching
85
Encourages active reading, deductive reasoning, logic, and attention to detail as kids try to piece together clues alongside the main character.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Active clue-tracking gives young readers enough evidence to attempt solving the mystery before Agatha reveals the answer.
Secret society world-building featuring London's underground tunnels and the Gatekeepers' Guild keeps the adventure moving.
Classic detective style offers the charm of traditional whodunits upgraded with a sharp, modern 13-year-old lead.
⚠
What to Watch For
Off-page murder: The title mentions murder, but the crime occurs off-stage and contains no graphic descriptions, keeping it firmly in cozy middle-grade territory.
Sequel status: While this is the second book in the series, it provides enough backstory that kids can dive in even if they missed book one.
Conversation Starters
"If you were hiding a secret clue inside a museum exhibit, where would you put it?"
"Which detail in the investigation made you suspicious first?"
"If you could join a secret society like the Gatekeepers' Guild, what would your specialty be?"
Deep Dive
Sleuthing for the screen-weary tween
Cozy mysteries are having a quiet moment in middle-grade fiction, and Agatha Oddly: Murder at the Museum sits right near the top of the stack. Author Lena Jones builds a detective story that feels sophisticated to an upper-elementary reader without dropping them into dark or distressing themes. The plot sets Agatha against a high-stakes investigation at the British Museum while she navigates her spot in the secret Gatekeepers' Guild.
Why it works for reluctant readers
What makes this book land so well with kids who usually prefer video games is its structure. Short chapters, clean pacing, and a lead character who relies on observation keep pages turning quickly. Rather than keeping key facts hidden to force a surprise ending, the narrative lays out the evidence in real time. Kids who enjoy puzzle games, escape rooms, or code-cracking will spend the second half of the book trying to beat Agatha to the reveal.
If your reader has already finished Enola Holmes or Robin Stevens' Murder Most Unladylike series, this is a seamless next pick.