A Wizard's Guide to Defensive Baking – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

A Wizard's Guide to Defensive Baking

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2020

87%

WISE Score

4.5

Amazon

A 14-year-old with bread magic saves her city from war—yes, really, and it's fantastic.

A Wizard's Guide to Defensive Baking

book

2020

87%

WISE Score

4.5

Amazon

A 14-year-old with bread magic saves her city from war—yes, really, and it's fantastic.

4.5

Jump to

Also rated on

4.5

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is what cozy fantasy should be: genuinely comforting while still having teeth. Kingfisher takes a premise that could be purely silly (bread magic!) and builds a real story around it—one with political intrigue, war, moral complexity, and a protagonist who feels like an actual teenager, not a sanitized version of one.

The book doesn't pull punches about the fact that war is terrible and adults often fail kids, but it also doesn't wallow in darkness. Mona's journey from 'I just want to make cinnamon rolls' to 'I guess I'm defending the city with a sourdough golem' is both hilarious and genuinely moving.

It's accessible enough for younger middle-graders but sophisticated enough that adults are genuinely enjoying it (see: the Reddit threads). The 4.5 Amazon rating and glowing reviews from multiple book sites back this up. If your kid is ready for books where people die but not ready for full YA intensity, this is the sweet spot.

Age Fit

Best for ages 10-14, though mature 9-year-olds who've read Percy Jackson or similar will be fine. The upper range extends to adults—this is one of those middle-grade books that doesn't feel like you're reading down. If your kid loved Howl's Moving Castle or Nevermoor, this is a great next step.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

A genuinely kind-hearted story about a girl with unconventional magic who rises to defend her city. Models courage, resourcefulness, and standing up for others. The protagonist is relatable and earnest without being saccharine. Handles serious themes (political corruption, war, death) with appropriate gravity but maintains emotional balance. The found-family dynamics and mentorship elements are warm without being preachy.

Imaginative

Bread magic. Just... bread magic. The premise alone is delightfully creative—a wizard whose familiar is a sourdough starter and who can only animate baked goods. Kingfisher takes an absurd concept and builds a fully-realized magic system around it. The world-building is colorful and whimsical (gingerbread men that dance, a massive sourdough golem) while still feeling grounded. It's the kind of book that makes kids think 'what if MY weird skill could save the world?'

Safe

Rated 'Mild' by RatedReads for general violence and peril, with scenes featuring siege, battle, and death. The book opens with Mona finding a dead body in her bakery, and there's an assassin hunting magic users. However, the violence isn't graphic or gratuitous—it's handled in an age-appropriate middle-grade way. The darker themes (political betrayal, war, children being used as weapons) are present but not traumatizing. No sexual content, no profanity. The main safety consideration is whether your kid is ready for 'people die in war' stakes.

Enriching

Tackles surprisingly meaty themes for a book about magical bread: what happens when adults fail you, how ordinary people become heroes, the ethics of using children in warfare, political corruption, and resource scarcity during conflict. Mona grapples with real moral complexity—she's terrified and angry and doesn't want to be a hero, which makes her journey more meaningful. The book doesn't talk down to kids about hard topics. Also subtly explores class dynamics and the value of 'lesser' magic. Plus, it's just really entertaining.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

The magic system is brilliantly absurd: sourdough starters as familiars, combat gingerbread men, and eventually a massive bread golem defending the city
Mona is a genuinely great protagonist—scared, angry, resourceful, and very much a kid thrust into impossible circumstances
T. Kingfisher doesn't shy away from complex themes (political betrayal, war, adults failing children) but handles them with middle-grade appropriate care
It's cozy fantasy that still has real stakes—people die, the city is under siege, and Mona has to figure out how her 'useless' magic can actually matter
Fast-paced and funny while also being thoughtful—the rare book that works for both younger readers branching into YA and adults who want something lighter

⚠

What to Watch For

Opens with Mona finding a dead body in her aunt's bakery—not graphic, but it sets a more serious tone than the whimsical premise suggests
Contains battle scenes, siege warfare, and characters dying (including children being used as weapons)—handled tastefully but present
Themes of political corruption and adults abandoning their responsibilities might hit hard for sensitive kids
Despite the cozy label, this has real emotional weight and might be intense for younger middle-graders

Conversation Starters

"Mona thinks her bread magic is useless compared to 'real' wizards. What skills do you have that might seem small but could be really important?"
"The adults in charge abandoned the city when things got hard. When have you seen grown-ups make bad choices, and what happened?"
"If you could have any weird, specific magic power like Mona's bread magic, what would it be?"
"Mona didn't want to be a hero and was scared the whole time. Do you think you can be brave and terrified at the same time?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about A Wizard's Guide to Defensive Baking? Put this WISE score on your site