Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is the kind of YA contemporary that actually matters. Tahereh Mafi (of Shatter Me fame) delivers a semi-autobiographical story that doesn't sugarcoat the post-9/11 experience for Muslim teens—the stares, the slurs, the violence—while still finding room for breakdancing, music, and a genuinely sweet first love.

The 4.6 Amazon rating and National Book Award recognition aren't flukes. This book does important empathy work, giving non-Muslim readers a window into daily discrimination while offering Muslim teens validation that their experiences are real and worth telling. The romance between Shirin and Ocean could've been cringey but instead feels authentic because Mafi doesn't rush past the legitimate barriers between them.

It's heavy, no question. Parents should know their teens will encounter racism, physical violence, and the emotional toll of being targeted for your identity. But it's not gratuitous—it's honest. And in 2025, when Islamophobia is still very much a thing, this 2002-set story remains essential reading for building understanding across difference.

Not a breezy beach read, but a worthy one that teens will actually finish (unlike some well-meaning but boring issue books). The breakdancing scenes provide levity, the family dynamics feel real, and Shirin's voice is sharp enough to keep pages turning even when the content gets tough.

Age Fit

Best for ages 12-17, the sweet spot for readers ready to grapple with serious discrimination and hate crimes while still connecting with a teen romance. The 2002 setting provides some historical distance that can make the heavy content slightly more digestible, though the themes remain current.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

82

Explores post-9/11 Islamophobia and first love with emotional maturity. Shirin's protective walls and gradual opening up model authentic teen emotional processing. The relationship with Ocean James shows healthy cross-cultural connection. Does deal with physical violence, racism, and discrimination, but handles it with purpose rather than exploitation. Strong family bonds through breakdancing with her brother add warmth.

Imaginative

68

Contemporary realistic fiction set in 2002, so limited fantastical elements. The breakdancing culture and music as emotional outlets provide creative expression. The exploration of identity and building bridges between 'irreconcilable worlds' requires readers to imagine beyond their own experience. Not particularly inventive in structure or storytelling approach, but the specific cultural lens offers fresh perspective for many readers.

Safe

72

Common Sense Media rates it 12+, Amazon suggests 13-17 years (grades 7-9). Contains depictions of racism, physical violence against the protagonist, and the emotional trauma of being targeted for wearing hijab. These are real-world issues presented for educational/empathetic purposes, not gratuitous. First love storyline is age-appropriate for teens. The difficult content is expected given the synopsis and genre (Prejudice & Racism), so no surprise factor for readers picking this up. Not suitable for younger kids who aren't ready for discussions of hate crimes and discrimination.

Enriching

88

Longlisted for National Book Award. Provides crucial window into Muslim-American teen experience post-9/11, building empathy and understanding of Islamophobia's real impact. For Muslim readers, offers important representation and validation. Explores complex themes of identity, prejudice, fear, and human connection across difference. The 2002 setting provides historical context for understanding current events. Strong character development shows growth through adversity. Amazon rating of 4.6/5 suggests readers find it impactful.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

National Book Award longlisted—this is literary YA with real weight and craft
Provides essential perspective on post-9/11 Muslim-American experience that's often missing from school curricula
The breakdancing subplot adds unexpected joy and sibling connection amid the heavier themes
First love story that crosses cultural divides feels earned, not cheesy—Ocean James actually does the work to understand Shirin
For Muslim teens especially, offers representation that validates their experiences and challenges

⚠

What to Watch For

Depicts physical violence, racist slurs, and daily microaggressions—this isn't light reading
Set in 2002 but themes remain painfully relevant; might spark difficult conversations about current events
Some teens may find Shirin's walls frustrating early on, though that's kind of the point
The romance is sweet but the discrimination content means this needs readers mature enough to process hate crimes

Conversation Starters

"Shirin uses breakdancing and music to cope—what do you do when you're frustrated or hurt by how people treat you?"
"Ocean's friends and family have different reactions to him dating Shirin. Why do you think people responded so differently?"
"The book is set in 2002, right after 9/11. How do you think things have changed or stayed the same for Muslim Americans since then?"
"Shirin keeps her guard up to protect herself. When is it smart to have walls, and when do they hold you back?"
"Have you ever had to explain or defend part of your identity to people who didn't understand it? What was that like?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

A Very Large Expanse of Sea