Look, we all know the streaming wars are real. You're probably paying for at least three services right now, wondering if you actually need them all, and specifically whether Netflix AND Disney+ are both justified line items in your family budget. Let's cut through the noise and figure out which one actually serves your kids better—or whether you need both at all.
The short answer? It depends on your kids' ages and what you value most. But let's dig into the details so you can make an informed call.
Disney+ is the fortress of franchises. You get the entire Disney vault, all the Pixar films, the Marvel universe, Star Wars everything, and National Geographic content. It's curated, it's safe, and honestly? It's a bit predictable. Your kids will watch Bluey on repeat (no complaints there—Bluey is genuinely great), binge every Marvel show, and cycle through the same Disney movies they've seen seventeen times already.
Netflix is the chaos goblin of streaming. The catalog is massive and wildly inconsistent. You'll find absolute gems like Avatar: The Last Airbender and innovative originals, but you'll also stumble into content that makes you wonder who greenlit this stuff. Netflix invests heavily in kids' content, but quality varies dramatically. Some shows are thoughtful and engaging; others are pure brain rot designed to keep eyeballs glued to screens.
The reality: Disney+ wins for younger kids (ages 3-8) who want familiar characters and safe content. Netflix edges ahead for tweens and teens (ages 9+) who need more variety and are ready for slightly more complex storytelling.
This is where things get interesting.
Disney+ parental controls are straightforward but basic. You can set up kids' profiles that only show G, PG, and TV-Y/TV-Y7 content. You can also set a PIN for more mature content. That's... pretty much it. The good news? The entire catalog is relatively safe, so you're less likely to have "how did my 6-year-old end up watching that?" moments.
Netflix parental controls are more robust because they need to be—the catalog is massive and includes everything from preschool shows to true crime documentaries. You can set maturity ratings by profile, require PINs for specific ratings, and even block individual titles. The Kids profile is pretty locked down, but here's the catch: Netflix's algorithm is aggressive. Even in Kids mode, it'll push content constantly, and not all of it is quality.
The verdict: If you want set-it-and-forget-it simplicity, Disney+ wins. If you're willing to spend 20 minutes setting things up properly and periodically checking in, Netflix's controls are more granular.
Disney+'s algorithm is relatively tame. It'll suggest more Marvel if they watched Marvel, more Pixar if they watched Pixar. Predictable and safe.
Netflix's algorithm is designed to maximize watch time, full stop. It's very good at its job, which means it's very good at serving up the next thing that'll keep your kid watching. Sometimes that's great—they discover a new show they love. Sometimes it's problematic—they end up in a content spiral of increasingly mindless viewing.
Here's what I see happening: Kids on Disney+ tend to rewatch favorites. Kids on Netflix tend to graze through tons of content, often not even finishing shows before moving to the next thing. Neither is inherently better or worse, but it's worth knowing the pattern.
Disney+: Around $8/month (with ads) or $14/month (ad-free). You can bundle it with Hulu and ESPN+ for better value if you want adult content too. The catalog doesn't change much—you're paying for access to established franchises and the occasional new release.
Netflix: Starts at $7/month (with ads), but the ad-free Standard plan at $15.49/month is what most families need for multiple devices. The catalog changes constantly—shows come and go, new originals drop regularly.
Real talk: If you have young kids who love Disney characters, Disney+ is a no-brainer. If you have older kids or multiple children at different ages, Netflix's variety makes more sense. Many families end up with both, rotating which one they actively use based on what's new.
Not all screen time is created equal, and we need to be honest about this.
Disney+ content tends to be more consistently produced with higher budgets and better storytelling. Even the "lesser" Disney Channel shows have basic narrative structure. The worst thing your kid will probably watch on Disney+ is mediocre, not actively terrible.
Netflix kids' content is a complete mixed bag. You'll find legitimately excellent shows like Hilda and The Dragon Prince, but you'll also find low-budget animated shows that are essentially digital pacifiers—bright colors, loud noises, zero substance. Check out our guide to identifying quality vs. brain rot content if you want to develop your radar for this.
If you have teenagers, this conversation changes completely. Disney+ has limited appeal for most teens beyond Marvel and Star Wars content. Netflix has a much deeper catalog of teen-appropriate content, though you'll need to be more involved in monitoring what they're watching.
The teenage years are when you shift from "controlling what they watch" to "talking about what they're watching." Netflix's variety gives you more opportunities for those conversations, but it also means more potential landmines. Here's how to navigate streaming with teens.
Choose Disney+ if:
- Your kids are under 8
- You want maximum safety with minimum effort
- Your family loves Disney/Pixar/Marvel/Star Wars
- You value rewatching favorites over discovering new content
Choose Netflix if:
- Your kids are 9+
- You want more variety and international content
- You're willing to be more hands-on with monitoring
- You have kids at different ages with different interests
Get both if:
- You can afford it without stress
- You have multiple kids spanning different age ranges
- You want to rotate based on what's new/interesting
Get neither if:
- You're trying to reduce overall screen time (honestly, having fewer options helps)
- Your kids are content with free options like YouTube Kids or library apps
- You'd rather invest in other activities
-
Look at your actual viewing habits. Most streaming services let you see watch history. What are your kids actually watching? Is it mostly one service?
-
Try the pause approach. Cancel one for a month and see if anyone really misses it. You can always resubscribe.
-
Set up proper controls NOW. Whichever service(s) you keep, spend the time setting up profiles and restrictions properly. Future you will be grateful.
-
Have the conversation. Talk to your kids about why you're choosing what you're choosing. It's a good opportunity to discuss media literacy and family values around screen time.
The streaming decision isn't just about content—it's about how streaming fits into your family's digital life. There's no universally right answer, just the right answer for your specific household right now. And that answer can change, which is the beauty of subscription services.
Want to dig deeper into specific shows or get personalized recommendations? Ask our chatbot about age-appropriate content for your kids
.