Shelby Van Pelt ruined you. You finished Remarkably Bright Creatures, closed the cover, and realized that 90% of the "heartwarming" fiction out there is actually just saccharine, emotionally manipulative fluff. You want the feeling of Tova and Marcellus—that specific, rare blend of grief, found family, gentle humor, and hyper-observant quirkiness—without feeling like you're reading a Hallmark movie script.
The good news is that the "curmudgeon finds a community" and "weirdos heal together" genres have some genuinely brilliant entries. You just have to know how to filter out the overly syrupy stuff to find the books that actually earn your tears.
Here is the TL;DR: If you're chasing the high of Remarkably Bright Creatures, skip the generic bestseller fluff and go for books that balance humor with real emotional weight. Anxious People delivers the ultimate grumpy-people-finding-connection narrative, while Lessons in Chemistry gives you another brilliant, observant animal narrator. For pure, un-cringe found family vibes, The Guncle hits the exact same sweet spot of navigating grief through unexpected, chaotic connections.
If your favorite part of Remarkably Bright Creatures was watching a closed-off, grieving person slowly get worn down by the sheer force of other people's chaotic goodwill, this is your lane.
Fredrik Backman is the undisputed king of the "grumpy person learns to love again" trope (he wrote A Man Called Ove, which is the canon recommendation here), but Anxious People is his masterpiece. A bank robber accidentally takes a group of highly annoying, deeply flawed people hostage at an apartment viewing. It is laugh-out-loud funny, structurally brilliant, and sneaks up on you with profound observations about the messy business of being human.
A.J. Fikry is a widowed, irritable bookstore owner living on a small island (hitting those Pacific Northwest isolation vibes, even though it's set in Massachusetts). His life is a rigid routine of drinking and judging people's reading tastes until a toddler is literally abandoned in his bookstore. It sounds like a setup for a cheesy sitcom, but Zevin writes with such sharp wit and genuine love for books about human connection that it completely bypasses the cringe factor.
Marcellus the giant Pacific octopus was the breakout star of Remarkably Bright Creatures. If you loved the chapters from a highly intelligent, slightly condescending animal's point of view, you need these.
You've probably heard of this one, but it belongs here specifically for Six-Thirty. He is a failed bomb-sniffing dog who knows hundreds of English words and serves as the quiet, fiercely loyal protector of the protagonist's family. The chapters where we get Six-Thirty's internal monologue about the absurdities of human behavior hit the exact same comedic and emotional notes as Marcellus's observations from his tank.
This is a deep cut, and it's non-fiction, but don't let that stop you. Sy Montgomery is a naturalist, and this memoir is told through 13 animals that shaped her life—including, yes, a giant Pacific octopus. If you want to dive deeper into the actual, mind-blowing intelligence of octopuses and the profound ways humans and animals can connect, this book is quiet, beautiful, and deeply moving.
Sometimes you just want a book that feels like a warm hug, but you still want the writing to be sharp. These books deal with heavy themes—grief, abandonment, identity—but wrap them in environments you desperately want to live in.
Patrick is a once-famous gay sitcom star living out his semi-retirement in Palm Springs, day-drinking and avoiding his feelings. When family tragedy strikes, he suddenly finds himself as the primary caretaker for his young niece and nephew. It is incredibly funny, deeply glamorous, and tackles books about grief and healing with a lightness that makes the emotional gut-punches land even harder.
If you're open to a tiny bit of magic, this is the coziest book on the list. Mika Moon is an isolated witch who gets hired to travel to a mysterious house to teach three young, unruly witches how to control their magic. It features a grumpy librarian, a chaotic household, and a protagonist who has never belonged anywhere finally finding her people. It's the literary equivalent of a perfect cup of tea.
This is the ultimate deep cut. There is no major trauma plot, no high-stakes drama, and no forced conflict. It is simply a book about two gentle, thirty-something introverts who are best friends, just trying to navigate a loud world that doesn't really understand them. It is profoundly kind, deceptively smart, and will completely cure your book hangover.
Pivot to audiobooks. One of the reasons Remarkably Bright Creatures hit so hard for so many people was the audiobook production—specifically Michael Urie voicing Marcellus. If you're struggling to get into a new book, try listening to it. Anxious People and Lessons in Chemistry both have phenomenal, award-winning audiobook narrations that bring the humor and the heart to the surface immediately.
If you're reading alongside a teenager who loved RBC, ask them which perspective they preferred: Tova's or Cameron's. It's a great backdoor into a conversation about whether they relate more to the feeling of being stuck in the past (Tova) or terrified of the future (Cameron).
Q: What age is Remarkably Bright Creatures appropriate for? It's great for ages 13 and up. There's nothing explicitly inappropriate for younger kids, but the themes of aging, outliving your child, and mid-life aimlessness resonate much better with older teens and adults.
Q: Are there other books with animal narrators like Marcellus the octopus? Yes. Lessons in Chemistry features a highly intelligent dog named Six-Thirty who observes human behavior, and The Art of Racing in the Rain is famously narrated by a dog, though it leans much heavier into tear-jerker territory than Remarkably Bright Creatures.
Q: What is the best book for someone who loved the grumpy protagonist trope? Anxious People by Fredrik Backman is the top pick. It masters the art of taking characters who seem insufferable on page one and making you deeply love them by the end of the book.
Q: Is there a sequel to Remarkably Bright Creatures? No, Shelby Van Pelt wrote it as a standalone novel. The ending wraps up the character arcs cleanly, making it a complete, self-contained story.
- Find more books like this
using the Screenwise chatbot. - Looking for reads the whole family can agree on? Check out our best books for kids list.
- If your high schooler is burning through these recommendations, browse our digital guide for high school for more media that hits the right emotional notes.