Vow of Silence – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Vow of Silence

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

show2024

58%

WISE Score

7.3

IMDb

A respectful deep-dive into Annie Mae Aquash's 1970s murder and the 30-year fight for justice—heavy, but important.

7.3/10

→

Vow of Silence

show

TV-MA, 2024

58%

WISE Score

7.3

IMDb

A respectful deep-dive into Annie Mae Aquash's 1970s murder and the 30-year fight for justice—heavy, but important.

7.3

Jump to

Also rated on

7.3/10

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

This isn't your typical true crime binge—it's a serious, well-crafted documentary about a murder that exposes decades of injustice within the American Indian Movement and law enforcement. Reviews praise its research, balance, and rare ability to deliver actual closure.

It's not for kids. The content is heavy, the subject matter is tragic, and it requires emotional maturity to process. But for high schoolers learning about Indigenous rights or adults who want substantive true crime that actually teaches something, this is solid.

The WISE score reflects its strengths (genuinely enriching, respectfully made) balanced against the reality that it's a murder documentary—not wholesome, not imaginative, and definitely not safe for younger viewers. But if your teen is ready for it, this is the kind of true crime that matters.

Age Fit

This is for high schoolers (14+) and adults. The subject matter—murder, systemic injustice, and decades of cover-up—is too heavy for younger teens. Best for viewers who can process complex historical trauma and are interested in social justice or true crime with substance.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

This is a true crime documentary about a murder that went unsolved for 30 years. While it's described as 'classy' and well-researched rather than sensationalized, the subject matter—assassination, injustice, and violence against Indigenous women—is inherently heavy and disturbing. It's not emotionally healthy viewing for younger audiences, though it handles the material with respect rather than exploitation.

Imaginative

As a historical true crime documentary, this doesn't invite creative expression or exploration. It's investigative journalism—important and well-crafted, but not particularly imaginative in the sense of sparking curiosity or wonder. It tells a specific, tragic story with a focus on facts and justice rather than creative storytelling.

Safe

This is a murder documentary about an assassination and decades of injustice. Common Sense Media rates it 14+, which tracks—it's not graphic or exploitative based on reviews, but the core content involves violence, death, and systemic failures. Not something a kid should stumble upon unexpectedly. It's designed for mature audiences who can process heavy historical trauma.

Enriching

This is where the documentary shines. It's described as 'well-researched,' tells 'both sides of the story,' and delivers 'a satisfying conclusion that most true crime docs don't deliver.' It educates viewers about Indigenous rights activism, the American Indian Movement, and a case of injustice that took 30 years to resolve. For teens and adults, it offers meaningful insight into systemic issues, Native American history, and the pursuit of justice. The 7.2 IMDb rating and positive reviews suggest it's engaging and substantive.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Tells an important story about Indigenous rights activism and the American Indian Movement that deserves wider attention
Described as classy and well-researched, avoiding the sensationalism that plagues most true crime docs
Actually delivers a satisfying conclusion—rare in this genre—after exploring both sides of a complex case
Educational about systemic injustices faced by Native American women and the long pursuit of accountability
For teens interested in social justice, history, or investigative journalism, this offers substantive, real-world learning

⚠

What to Watch For

This is about a murder and decades of cover-up—14+ minimum, and even then, best for teens who can handle heavy historical trauma
The subject matter is inherently sad and frustrating; it's not light viewing and deals with violence against women and systemic failures
While not gratuitously graphic, the core story involves death and injustice that younger kids shouldn't be exposed to

Conversation Starters

"What did you learn about the American Indian Movement and why Annie Mae was involved in activism?"
"Why do you think it took 30 years to solve this case? What systems failed her?"
"How does this story connect to current issues around missing and murdered Indigenous women?"
"What does justice look like when it takes decades to arrive?"

Deep Dive

Beyond the Crime Scene

True crime has a habit of focusing on the "how" of a murder while treating the "why" as a background texture. Vow of Silence flips that. It spends as much time on the internal politics of the American Indian Movement (AIM) as it does on the forensic details of Annie Mae Aquash’s death. This is less about a mystery and more about a betrayal.

If your teen is used to the fast-paced, neon-soaked style of Netflix crime docs, they might find the pacing here a bit deliberate. It’s a slow-burn history lesson masquerading as a cold case investigation. But that slower speed is exactly why it works. It gives the viewer space to sit with the reality of the 1970s political landscape. It avoids the cheap thrills of the genre and opts for something that feels more like a political thriller.

The Activism Angle

For a high schooler, the most interesting part isn't necessarily the 30-year search for justice. It’s the look at what happens when a social movement becomes paranoid. The show does a great job of showing how external pressure from law enforcement can cause a group to turn on its own members.

If you’re watching this with a student, it’s worth reading up on the true story behind the Vow of Silence and Annie Mae's assassination to help frame the conversation around activism and identity. The series doesn't just point fingers at "the bad guys"; it asks tough questions about the people Annie Mae considered her allies. It’s a nuanced take on how systemic pressure can break down community trust.

Why It Sticks

Most true crime leaves you with a lingering sense of unease or a "to be continued" title card. This one is different because it actually provides closure.

Critics and fans on Reddit have noted that the series manages to be informative without feeling like a dry textbook. It’s a heavy watch, certainly, but it’s the kind of content that earns its runtime. If your kid liked Killers of the Flower Moon or is interested in the Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW) movement, this is the modern-day context they need.

The Vibe: Serious, respectful, and deeply researched.
The Friction: It deals with systemic failures that can be incredibly frustrating to watch.
The Payoff: A rare, satisfying conclusion to a decades-old injustice.

Don't expect a light weekend binge. This is a show meant for focused viewing and the kind of conversation that lasts long after the credits roll. It’s true crime with substance.

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic