2019
WISE Score
Amazon
Homer’s classic war epic gets a cinematic, bloody, and surprisingly readable glow-up that won’t make your teen want to throw the book at a wall.
4.8
4.8View →Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)
This isn't your grandma's dusty Iliad. Gareth Hinds has done the impossible by making one of the most intimidating books in history feel like a page-turner.
It’s gritty, it’s gorgeous, and it doesn't talk down to the reader. While the battle scenes are visceral, they serve the story rather than just aiming for shock value. If you want your kid to actually understand the classics without the 'brain rot' of a SparkNotes summary, this is the gold standard.
Perfect for 12 and up. If they can handle a PG-13 Marvel movie or a Percy Jackson book, they can handle this—though the emotional weight here is much heavier.
It handles heavy themes like pride, rage, and the brutal reality of war with maturity. While it's a 'war story,' it focuses on the weight of human emotion rather than mindless destruction.
Gareth Hinds’ visual world-building is top-tier. He takes 3,000-year-old poetry and turns it into a cinematic experience that feels both ancient and immediate.
It's the Trojan War, so expect spears, blood, and grim deaths. It’s not 'unsafe' for teens, but it’s definitely too intense for a casual bedtime story for the little ones.
This is essentially the DNA of Western literature. Hinds makes a notoriously difficult classic accessible, including maps and character guides that actually help you keep the plot straight.
Most people remember The Iliad as a literal brick of a book they were forced to skim in high school. Gareth Hinds takes that 3,000-year-old slog and turns it into something that feels more like a prestige HBO miniseries. This is a massive, ambitious adaptation that treats the source material with total respect while acknowledging that modern readers need a visual hook to keep the fifty different Greek guys with similar names straight.
We usually tell kids to avoid shortcuts, but this is the rare case where the visual version might actually be superior for a first-time encounter. Hinds includes a comprehensive cast of characters and color-coded armor that solves the "who is dying now?" problem that plagues the original text. If your kid is currently struggling through a classical literature unit, this isn't just a supplement; it’s a Rosetta Stone.
It’s worth noting that while this is a companion to Hinds’ previous work, you should check out The Odyssey: Is the Visual Version Too Intense for Your Kid? to see how the two compare. The Iliad is much more focused on the grinding, repetitive nature of war, whereas The Odyssey is a monster-of-the-week adventure.
The 4.8 rating on Amazon isn't just because the art is pretty. It’s because Hinds doesn't sanitize the Bronze Age. When a spear hits someone, you see exactly where it goes. It’s visceral, but it’s never gratuitous. The violence here serves to highlight the "grim glory" the synopsis mentions—it makes the stakes feel real rather than just mythological.
If your reader has moved on from the lighter tone of the Wings of Fire graphic novels and is looking for something with more weight, this is the perfect bridge. It occupies a similar space to The Hedge Knight in terms of its grounded, gritty approach to combat and honor.
The most interesting choice Hinds makes is how he depicts the gods. They aren't glowing, ethereal beings; they are petty, giant-sized manipulators who look like they’re playing a tabletop wargame with human lives. It’s a great way to show teens how the ancient Greeks viewed fate. One minute a hero is winning because he’s brave, and the next, a god literally trips him so the other guy can win. It’s frustrating, weird, and exactly how the original epic intended it to feel.
This isn't a "gateway" book for reluctant readers like Minecraft: The Graphic Novel. This is for the kid who wants to sink their teeth into a complex narrative and come out the other side actually understanding why people are still talking about Achilles' heel three millennia later.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
