No Thank You, Evil!

No Thank You, Evil!

Board Game

5+, 2016, Children's Game, Fantasy

WISE
93%

WISE Score

7.4

Board Game Geek

D&D for kindergarteners—a storytelling adventure game where imagination is the only rule and parents get to be the dungeon master.

Amazon4.7
Board Game Geek7.4
Common Sense Media

Where to Play

Amazon
Amazon

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is one of those rare games that does exactly what it promises: gets young kids into creative storytelling and role-playing without the intimidation factor of traditional RPGs.

The genius is in the simplicity—kids pick a few traits, get some basic 'powers,' and then just... make stuff up together. The Guide (usually a parent) presents problems, and kids solve them using imagination plus light game mechanics. It's structured enough to feel like a real game but loose enough that a 6-year-old can succeed.

The catch? It requires an adult who's willing to improvise and play along. If you're the type who groans at pretend play, this will feel like work. But if you enjoy collaborative storytelling, this is legitimately fun for the whole family. Reviews consistently praise the materials and how well it works with the target age group.

It's not going to compete with screens for attention, but for families intentionally creating screen-free bonding time, this is a winner.

Age Fit

Perfect for ages 5-10, with the sweet spot around 6-8. Younger kids can play with patient guidance; older kids may want more complex RPG systems like Hero Kids or actual D&D. Adults won't play this solo, but engaged parents will genuinely enjoy running sessions.

WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92

A cooperative storytelling game designed specifically for families, with emphasis on creative problem-solving, friendship, and adventure. The Guide role (often a parent) creates a collaborative rather than competitive experience. Content is explicitly kid-friendly with whimsical scenarios like 'Dragonsnot Falls' that are silly without being crude. Models positive social dynamics through shared narrative building.

Imaginative
96

This is essentially imagination-as-a-game. Players create characters from descriptive traits and collectively build stories through role-playing. The open-ended storytelling mechanic means every session is different. The game actively fires up creative thinking rather than following rigid paths—you're literally making up adventures together. Multiple reviews emphasize the 'creative make-believe' aspect as the core mechanic.

Safe
95

Board games are inherently safe, and this one particularly so. Fantasy adventure content is age-appropriate for 5+. The cooperative structure avoids the toxic competition that can arise in some games. No mature themes, no concerning artwork based on available info. The Guide role provides built-in adult oversight. Only minor consideration: younger kids might need help with the 1.7 complexity rating, but that's developmental, not a safety issue.

Enriching
88

Develops multiple skills: storytelling, creative problem-solving, social collaboration, and basic role-playing game mechanics. The Guide role teaches leadership and facilitation. Players practice narrative thinking and working through challenges with character abilities. It's essentially a gateway to tabletop RPGs, which build executive function and social skills. Entertainment value is high based on reviews, though replay value depends on the Guide's creativity.

Parent Info
✓

Why It Might Be Great

  • Introduces tabletop RPG concepts to kids as young as 5 without overwhelming complexity (1.7 weight rating)
  • Every session is completely different because you're collectively making up stories—infinite replayability if your Guide is engaged
  • The cooperative structure means kids work together rather than competing, making it great for sibling bonding
  • Builds genuine skills: storytelling, creative problem-solving, taking turns, and thinking through challenges with limited 'abilities'
  • Parents get to be creative too—the Guide role is actually fun for adults who enjoy improvisation
⚠

What to Watch For

  • This game lives or dies by the Guide's engagement—if the adult running it phones it in, it'll flop
  • Younger 5-year-olds might struggle with the structure; 6-7 is probably the sweet spot for independent play
  • Some kids who prefer concrete rules and winning conditions may find the open-ended storytelling frustrating
  • 30-minute sessions can stretch longer if kids are really into it—plan accordingly

Conversation Starters

  • "What kind of character do you want to be? What makes them special or different from you?"
  • "How would YOUR character solve this problem? What would they try first?"
  • "What was your favorite part of our adventure today? What should we try next time?"
  • "If you could add any magical item or companion to your character, what would it be and why?"

Deep Dive

The "Mad Libs" approach to character building

The smartest thing about this game is how it handles character creation. In most RPG games for kids, you’re looking at numbers, health points, and modifiers that feel like homework. Here, you build a character using a sentence: "I'm a [Noun] who [Adjective] [Verb]s."

A five-year-old might just be a "Robot." That’s it. They get a few tokens and they’re ready. A seven-year-old can be a "Super-Smart Robot who Loves Pizza." This modularity is brilliant because it lets siblings of different ages play the same game without the older one feeling bored or the younger one feeling lost. The game effectively grows with the child’s vocabulary and attention span.

Managing the "Scary" stuff

The title isn't just a polite suggestion—it’s a literal gameplay mechanic. If the adventure gets too intense, or if a kid is genuinely creeped out by a monster the Guide (that’s you) describes, they can say, "No thank you, evil!" and the scary thing goes away or changes into something silly.

This is a masterclass in teaching agency. It gives kids a "stop button" for the narrative, which actually makes them more willing to take risks because they know they have ultimate control. It’s the opposite of the "tough it out" mentality found in older games, and it makes for a much smoother bedtime transition once the dice are put away.

The "Theatre Kid" vs. the "Math Kid"

If you’re looking for a tactical combat simulator where you track every arrow and gold coin, this isn't it. For that, you’d want something like Hero Kids or eventually the Parent’s Guide to Dungeons & Dragons.

No Thank You, Evil! sits firmly on the storytelling end of the spectrum. Success isn't always about rolling a high number; it’s about how you use your "Pool" of points (like Courage or Smartness) to help your friends. It’s collaborative by design. If your kid is the type who spends three hours building a backstory for their LEGO figures but hates doing subtraction, this is their favorite game.

The Guide's reality check

Let’s be real: you are the engine of this game. While the box comes with great maps and cards to help visualize the world of Storidada, the heavy lifting happens in your brain. You aren't just reading rules; you are performing.

If you’re exhausted and just want to scroll on your phone while the kids play, skip this. This is an "active parenting" game. However, the payoff is that you aren't just a referee; you’re the co-author of a story they’ll actually remember. The sessions are designed to be 30 minutes, which is the perfect "one more chapter" length for a Tuesday night. It’s high-effort, high-reward bonding that beats another round of Candy Land every single time.

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about No Thank You, Evil!? Put this WISE score on your site