Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

This is not entertainment in the traditional sense—it's a gut-punch of a history lesson that everyone should eventually watch, but only when they're ready.

Ava DuVernay created something remarkable here: a series that takes the dehumanizing headlines about the "Central Park Five" and restores the humanity, complexity, and dignity of Korey, Yusef, Antron, Kevin, and Raymond. The performances are stunning, the storytelling is masterful, and the educational value is off the charts.

But let's be clear: this is brutal. Police interrogations that feel like torture. Prison violence that's hard to watch. The slow, grinding horror of watching innocent teenagers lose years of their lives to a system that failed them at every turn. It's not gratuitous—it's necessary to understand what actually happened—but it's heavy.

For families with older teens (15+), this is essential viewing that will spark the kinds of conversations about race, justice, and power that we need to be having. Just don't press play without preparing your kid for what they're about to see, and plan time to process it together afterward. This one stays with you.

Age Fit

This is strictly for ages 15 and up—mature teens who can handle graphic depictions of injustice, violence, and trauma. Adults will find it powerful and essential, but younger viewers will be overwhelmed and potentially traumatized. Not for middle schoolers, period.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

65

Emotionally intense and often devastating, depicting systemic injustice, police coercion, and wrongful imprisonment. While it models resilience, family bonds, and the pursuit of truth, the tone is heavy and traumatic rather than uplifting. The emotional weight is purposeful and important, but not 'wholesome' in the traditional sense—it's a story about profound suffering and survival.

Imaginative

72

Ava DuVernay's direction is visually striking and narratively bold, using creative storytelling techniques to humanize the Central Park Five and illuminate systemic racism. The series invites viewers to question authority, understand perspective, and see beyond headlines. However, as a biographical drama rooted in real events, it doesn't offer the kind of open-ended creative exploration or world-building found in more imaginative fiction.

Safe

35

This is emphatically not safe for younger viewers. The series depicts police brutality, psychological torture during interrogations, prison violence (including a brutal assault), racial slurs, and references to sexual assault (the assault itself is never shown). Common Sense Media recommends age 15+, and parent reviews confirm it's emotionally intense and disturbing. Teens and adults can handle it with context, but it requires significant maturity and preparation.

Enriching

92

Extraordinary educational and empathetic value. This series teaches critical lessons about systemic racism, criminal justice failures, media manipulation, and the real-world consequences of prejudice. It builds empathy for marginalized communities, encourages critical thinking about authority, and provides essential context for understanding ongoing social justice movements. The acting, writing, and direction are all exceptional (96% RT critics, 8.8 IMDb, 86 Metacritic). This is the kind of media that changes how you see the world.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Teaches critical lessons about systemic racism, wrongful conviction, and how the justice system can fail—essential modern history
Exceptional performances and direction (96% critics score) that humanize the five young men beyond headlines
Builds deep empathy and encourages questioning of authority, media narratives, and institutional power
Sparks crucial conversations about race, justice, and resilience that families with older teens need to have
Based on true events that shaped criminal justice reform conversations for decades

⚠

What to Watch For

Extremely intense content: police coercion, psychological torture, prison violence, racial slurs, and references to sexual assault
Emotionally devastating and can be triggering—this is not background viewing, it requires full attention and processing time
Best watched with context and discussion, not alone—teens especially need support processing the injustice depicted
Some parents report their 15-year-olds found it too intense; know your kid's maturity level around trauma and violence

Conversation Starters

"What would you do if you were falsely accused of something serious? How would you prove your innocence?"
"Why do you think the police and prosecutors were so convinced these teenagers were guilty, even without real evidence?"
"How does the media coverage in the show compare to how news stories are covered today? What can we learn about believing headlines?"
"The series shows how systemic racism affects every level of the justice system—where did you see that happening?"
"How did the families stay strong through all of this? What would you need from your family in a crisis like this?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

When They See Us