This Christmas is a perfectly fine ensemble dramedy that tries to be the Black family answer to holiday classics like The Family Stone, but it never quite gets there. The cast is likable, the themes of forgiveness and showing up for family are solid, and audiences clearly connected with it more than critics did.

But let's be real: it's soapy, predictable, and doesn't bring much new to the table. The secrets-at-Christmas formula is well-worn, and while the Whitfields feel authentic, the resolutions feel tidy. It's the kind of movie that's pleasant in the moment but doesn't linger.

For families with older teens, it's a decent pick if you want to talk about real family messiness during the holidays. For younger kids? Hard pass—they'll be checking their phones within 20 minutes. And for adults? It's fine background viewing while you wrap presents, but you're not missing much if you skip it.